France should think before banning the burqa
Is anyone else experiencing déjà-vu listening to French president Nicolas Sarkozy’s discourse in recent weeks? Not content with having given the same speech about French farmers twice, at a mere twelve months’ interval, he thought it wise to bring up another national favourite during his public appearance in the Vercors district last week: wishing to bring his own ‘contribution’ to the debate on national identity, the president (re)asserted that ‘there is no place for the burqa on French territory’. Though France would never ask anyone to renounce their own history and culture, he added, a person wishing to become French should also adopt the prevailing national values. Wearing this traditional veil that covers a woman from head to toe is not, according to Mr. Sarkozy, in line with the ideas of the Republic about female dignity. These statements come in the middle of a controversial motion to ban women in France from wearing the burqa in public.
Well, isn’t that nice. Back in 2003, wearing the veil was wrong because it violated public school policy, now it is being decried as contrary to some elusive notion of ‘national identity’. But what is it exactly about wearing the veil that is so deeply offensive to French values? Is France adverse to women having modesty, and dressing to preserve it? Or is it just that the garment in question has become so stigmatized by the Taliban rule in Afghanistan that it is de facto a provocation against the rights and liberties that the West holds dear? Surely the French, and their president, are not so limited.
Nevertheless the issue arises time and time again, and on each occasion a league of middle-aged male politicians sets out to patronize women about what clothes will make them look most liberated. Of course, most of us are not greatly affected by this kind of discourse, and I personally would probably not consider ever wearing the burqa. No, I prefer to have a little more diversity in my closet. In fact, I exercise all of my wonderful Western liberties with the outfits that I wear: I own short skirts, sky-high heels, and fitted jackets, and depending on which of these I choose to put on I know that people will look at my legs, my waist, or even just my hair if I decide to let it down. I know that people will look at me and because of the education I received and the social norms I am used to, I don’t dwell for long on the nature of that look. But let it be said for the benefit of Mr. Sarkozy, that this has nothing to do with my dignity as a woman. I dress in clothes that I am comfortable appearing in publicly, and if another woman were to suffer to a greater degree from people looking at her, and did not want to be exposed to it, the dignified thing for her to do would be to wear long sleeves, to cover her legs, and for that matter to cover any part of her body she didn’t want subjected to scrutiny. And precisely because that woman is living in the Republic of France, she should be free to do so.
Now of course there are reasons to dislike the burqa specifically, as one cannot completely ignore the stigma attached to it, and the fact that it is a particularly popular item of clothing in societies that do repress women and constrain their liberties. Therefore, if the aim is to encourage unity in the French national identity, it will be necessary to resist intolerant and misogynist ideas being imported from abroad, and to fight them domestically. Yes, the French should resist the expansion of a culture that prevents its women from working, that denies women the right to socialize, and that dictates the way women should dress. Because that’s just wrong.
However maybe we have been too quick to judge Mr. Sarkozy. Let us not forget that in reaction to U.S. president Obama’s speech in Cairo earlier this year, in which he criticized Western states for trying to impose standard ways of dressing, his French counterpart lost no time in agreeing, as ostentatiously as possible, that women should have the right to wear the veil if they so please. As for his recent quips, well they will be music to the ears of that right-wing electorate that his party is so desperate to win over in view of the 2010 regional elections. So maybe Mr. Sarkozy is not really a bigot. Maybe he’s just dishonest.
