Fracking: scraping the bottom of the barrel?

By Bryony HockinRusty Shell oil barrel, titled "Tellus"

For those of us who’ve emerged, blinking in the sunlight, from the Durham bubble for the duration of the summer, one issue in the news seems unavoidable: fracking.

As someone who divides their time between Sussex and Durham, both lying on valuable shale gas deposits, I rapidly found myself having to develop opinions on an extremely emotive issue that until recently I knew nothing about.

Fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, is the process of extracting natural gas from shale rock by pumping water, sand and chemicals into the rock. This causes the rock to fracture and allows natural gas to escape and be collected. Originally this was used in American oil wells to collect the very last of the gas before the well was decommissioned; but recent discovery of shale gas across Britain has created a surge of interest from foreign oil companies.

Any student staring dejectedly at their gas bill can tell you that prices have skyrocketed in recent years; and in the wider world, politicians are wary of relying on Russia for our natural gas supplies.Additionally, alternative energy sources such as wind turbines, hydroelectric plants and solar panels require large investments to get started, something that a recession-struck country like Britain may be reluctant to do. So surely drilling for gas in Britain is the perfect solution to our growing energy needs? It’s even likely to boost the economy by providing jobs for British workers; but at what cost?

Is it possible that in their rush to follow in America’s footsteps, politicians have endorsed fracking as a magical solution to our energy needs without seeing the whole picture? America is a vast country, with a much lower population density than the UK; fracking in some genuinely unpopulated areas of the US, often in existing oil fields, is much less problematic than targeting a populated area in the UK. Ironically, fracking (which requires thousands of litres of fresh water) is currently carried out in some of the most drought-ridden areas of the US; likewise, fresh water is at a premium in the south-east of England. We have seen only the beginning of the thunderous descent of the oil industry on the tiny village of Balcombe (most recently in the news).

The biggest concern of residents of towns such as Balcombe is the disposal of the contaminated water used in fracking. The many chemicals used to clean and open the cracks in bore holes include toxins such as methanol, antifreeze and salts containing chromium and other poisonous metals. These can cause skin and eye irritation, respiratory problems and are harmful if swallowed; yet because treatment of this contaminated water is so expensive and time-consuming, disposal usually involves storing it deep underground in used oil wells.

This process of underground water storage, not fracking itself, has caused small earthquakes in the past. A recent fracking-related earthquake in Texas was just 4.8 on the Richter scale; not a huge concern for everyone on the surface, who might be knocked off their feet but left unharmed. But underground it is a different story; the seismic activity caused by this earthquake could easily crack the protective concrete surrounding the toxic water, allowing it to leak into the groundwater and go on to contaminate rivers and reservoirs. Maybe one day the energy companies will realise that you can’t solve your problems by burying them.

Our over-reliance on fossil fuels and corporations’ reluctance to invest in sustainable energy sources mean that we are going to greater lengths to get our fix of fossil fuels. These companies are stuck in their ways, thinking only of methods to make money now to appease shareholders, with no thought for the future.

One day, the reserves will run out; even fracking won’t be able to extract the fossil fuels that we so desperately need. Will the corporations still be clinging to their outdated idea of instant profit over people? Let’s hope not.

Photograph: Teemu Ylikoski