Formals: an essential or alienating experience?

By Dhillon Shenoy

Combination. Ladies and friends … awkward? You might be wondering what I’m going on about. But fellow Chadsians will likely recognise these as being just a small selection of the eclectic and occasionally quirky themes that characterise Tuesday and Thursday evenings in Moulsdale Hall.

 I remember well the Fresher’s Formal held for us on day one. A baptism by black gown, white tablecloth and the timeless yet dreaded introductory questions of “Which A levels did you take?”.

Now, let me be honest. I have been through one or two formals sat with a table that left me saying the closing grace “Deo Gratias” (Thank God) with sincerity – mainly for the imminent opportunity to leave with haste. Yes – gowns, Latin chants, and formality itself can make the occasion stuffy and alienating, but a valuable insight I have obtained is that the unfamiliarity and weirdness of the whole thing is something that most (if maybe not quite all) students feel — and, importantly, can share in and bond over together.

So I want to argue that formals should instead embody something in our post-pandemic world that is of universal value to all students — the power of community and coming together. For me, this hit home during my train journey back to Durham this January, when I found myself talking with a fellow Durham student and another passenger of a *slightly* more advanced generation.

None of us had ever met before we began our conversation. Yet, much like in a formal, the discussion was deep, wide-ranging, and only occasionally vulnerable to controversy (the mention of the Sussex household may have produced some turbulence). Our older companion also took the time to tell us about her son — a soldier who has served our country around the world including in Afghanistan — and the sheer delight she gets from spending time with her grandchildren. However, it was only upon her disembarkment at Darlington that she told my fellow student and I, not without some emotion, that we were the first people she had been able to have a meaningful face-to-face interaction with since early December.

Even before Covid-19, leaving home to go to university, and Durham in particular, could be far more isolating for some students than others. And let’s not pretend that this isn’t still the case. But now that we have all shared in a period, as our new Vice-Chancellor well-articulated, “of instability, privation and sadness”. Surely we can no longer take for granted the nourishing effect of shared experiences, sometimes unusual and peculiar, with friends?

The defining feature of any formal should not be gowns or Latin.

The same goes for challenging ourselves to reach out to new individuals — one of the things I have valued most about formals at Chad’s is the opportunity to befriend and connect with MCR and SCR members who might otherwise have remained undiscovered sources of wisdom. And the ban on mobile phones at the table can only be something to embrace in this age where the digital world has been allowed too much encroachment upon our everyday social lives.

Having only been to formals at Chad’s, I have little to no idea of the formal traditions of other colleges (do Hatfielders really bang their cutlery on the table?) — but I can promote some of the steps that our JCR has taken to make ours more accessible. Second-hand gown sales that save the environment as well as the student budget, a brand-new formalwear lending service, not to mention that the cost of meals are included for livers-in. And in light of the lower frequency of formals at maintained colleges (not to mention the recent Covid-19 related cancellation of one at St Mary’s), tribute must be made to the accomplishments of the Chad’s catering team who managed to keep up a formal dinner service twice a week last term and have now just resumed following the lifting of the ‘soft start’ restrictions.

Should we see formals as a vital part of the ‘Durham experience’? I have been told this is dependent on whether you are allocated a Bailey or Hill college. But I want to suggest that the defining feature of any college’s formal should not be gowns, prayers in Latin or underlying scrutiny and judgement from others, but rather the opportunity for introduction to and engagement with the passionate, funny and warm-hearted individuals that represent the best of what this University has to offer — a vibrant and enduring community that could not be more vital to any student’s time here, regardless of which college they belong to.

Illustration: Elle Fitzgerald.