Foreign Office ‘failed to protect’ Durham PhD student from UAE torture

By Eleanor Tait

Durham University PhD student, Matthew Hedges, has received an apology from the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) for their management of his arrest and torture in the United Arab Emirates (UAE).

Hedges was arrested by the UAE in Dubai Airport in May 2018 during a research trip and accused of being a British spy. He was released shortly after being sentenced to life imprisonment in November 2018 by a presidential pardon.

A complaint to the FCDO over the handling of his case was filed by Hedges earlier this year, which prompted an investigation carried out by the Parliamentary Ombudsman into the handling of his case.

 The ombudsman found that the FCDO did not follow the recommended procedures for torture cases; UAE guards were reportedly in attendance at all meetings between Hedges and Foreign Office consular officials, preventing Hedges from speaking openly.

UAE guards were reportedly in attendance at all meetings between Hedges and Foreign Office consular officials, preventing Hedges from speaking openly

In the apology, Sir Philip Barton, permanent undersecretary of the FCDO said: “On behalf of the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO), I acknowledge, and apologise for, the failings identified by the ombudsman, specifically I recognise that we did not fully follow our guidance on torture and mistreatment and that this failure has left you uncertain as to whether more could have been done on your behalf.”

Barton also said that the outcomes of their handling of the case were the same as if the given guidelines for assessing signs of torture had been followed.

Palatinate requested a comment from the Foreign Office regarding this but did not receive a response.

An FCDO spokesperson told The Independent: “We recognise that Mr Hedges’ and his family’s experience was a distressing one that has had a profound impact.

“We have accepted the ombudsman’s finding for Mr Hedges, apologised and will pay the suggested compensation.

“The ombudsman rejected elements of the complaint and its report concluded we did act correctly in seeking access to Mr Hedges. We always aim to act in the best interest of the individual and acting without their consent in raising concerns about torture and mistreatment creates unacceptable risks.

“Helping British nationals abroad is a top priority and we offer advice and support at any time of day or night, helping over 20,000 British people and their families every year.”

“Helping British nationals abroad is a top priority and we offer advice and support at any time of day or night, helping over 20,000 British people and their families every year.”

Alongside the apology, Hedges has received £1,500 from the FCDO in compensation for his experience with them.

Hedges, who has suffered post-traumatic stress disorder and insomnia as a result of his detention, has described the apology as “a watershed moment, not just for me and my family but for all British nationals”.

He continued: “There is now no doubt that the FCDO failed in their obligations towards one of their citizens, and I truly hope that the hundreds of other British nationals who are currently detained and suffering torture will benefit from the FCDO’s promise of reviewing their clearly outdated and insufficient policies.”

There is now no doubt that the FCDO failed in their obligations towards one of their citizens”

Following this investigation, the FCDO have planned to review their recommended procedures for cases of alleged torture, begin training their staff on handling similar detention cases, and make clearer the kinds of support British citizens should be able to expect when overseas.

Hedges is currently supporting fellow victims of false accusations and arrest abroad through his work with the Redress Trust.

With regards to the role of the FCDO in this he said: “I cannot overstate how fundamental it is that the FCDO improves its procedures for protecting British citizens that are detained abroad, especially for those like Jaghtar Singh Johal in India, and Alaa Abd El-Fattah in Egypt, who like me, have suffered torture at the hands of the authorities holding them – also British allies.”

In August the UAE government claimed it provided Mr Hedges with “entirely proper care and treatment. He was never subjected to, or threatened with, either torture or cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment of any sort. The UAE has evidence to support this.”

Image: Daniela Tejada