Football violence scars the beautiful game

by Anthony Gregory

The recent disastrous riots at Port Said stadium during an Egyptian football league match, which left 74 dead after a violent crush to escape the frenzied scenes, proved to be a tragic twist to a competitive fixture. In a state riddled with tensions, it has been difficult to determine exactly how much the violence was instigated by hooliganism, or whether a politically charged situation exacerbated a harrowing clash with police that proved deadly and destructive.

Some have blamed the events on the simmering rivalry between the competing Egyptian clubs al-Masry and al-Ahly, with the home team al-Masry celebrating the victory by forcefully confronting their fleeing opposition. Yet the police, by no means flavour of the times among many Egyptians who associate the authorities with repression, have also been held to account for inertia in not seizing dangerous objects upon entry to the stadium. They were even accused of “having a pop” at football fans who have been connected to recent revolutionary events.

The events at Port Said have been followed up by angry protests in Cairo; some angry that the police did not do more to help stricken fans inside the stadium, others directly venting anger and frustration that Egyptian rule has not been propelled into civilian hands. After initial widespread euphoria at the removal of Hosni Mubarak and the hope of a new chapter of development and freedom within Egypt, events have, it can be argued, conspired over the last year into a chain of disappointment and unfulfilled expectation for Egyptians. The catastrophe at al-Masry’s arena is another heartbreaking low for an emotional Egypt.

It is difficult to separate cause and effect from one another, but it would not be the first time in which football violence has possessed ideological roots. European football hooliganism has in some cases been linked to Neo-Nazism and other radical movements, with disorder connected to nationalistic groups in some Central and Eastern European countries.

The 1990 riot at the Dinamo Zagreb (Croatia) vs. Red Star Belgrade (Serbia) fixture was linked to tension amid Croatia’s breakaway movement seeking independence from Yugoslavia. Dinamo captain Zvonimir Boban famously used his foot against a Yugoslav policeman rather than the ball, defending one of his fans amid the carnage quite literally kicking off. Boban earned cult status among Croatians as a result, but football as a game paled into insignificance as the stadium became a battle-ground amid nationalistic tension bubbling over into toxicity. It is a miracle nobody was killed.

As a passionate Millwall fan, I have seen my club regularly associated with hooliganism and disorderly behaviour. Their rivalry with West Ham is legendary, and has roots of geographical fan bases glaring at one another over the River Thames. More quirkily it arose from rival shipyards that divided dockers decades ago.

Although games between the two teams can create an atmosphere crackling with effervescent excitement, lines have been crossed. The 2009 riots were a dangerous, deplorable blot on the landscape of English football, which has done well to largely stamp out crowd trouble since the dark days of the 1980s. Films such as Green Street create a dramatic image of a brutal fan base of both clubs, but one should remember that such fans are in a minority that, it is hoped, is ever-shrinking.

The famously volatile Celtic-Rangers rivalry is a different kettle of fish, a melting-pot of division and juxtaposition creating bitter animosity between the two Glaswegian clubs. Some cite traditionally differing religious roots as responsible for the fission: Rangers being historically “Protestant” and Celtic “Catholic”. Others have pointed to the political views and national roots of Celtic’s traditional Irish immigrant background contrasting with the British flag-waving Rangers fans. Blood has been spilt on several occasions in the name of the “Old Firm” rivalry, and as with any viciously competitive rivalry, fixtures prove to be a stressful day at the office for swollen police ranks.

Football must be careful not to become a smokescreen for a plethora of disagreements that bubble over into violence between fans or against the authorities. Some hooligans do not even understand the roots behind age-old rivalry, and the adoption of an “us” and “them” mentality can create a spark to fuse a football club together, but should not become an explosion that triggers injury and even death.

Football stadiums can be intimidating arenas, not only for fans but also for players and officials. Regardless of his performance, referee Tom Ovrebo should not have received death threats after the 2009 Champions League semi-final between Chelsea and Barcelona. The much-discussed Mario Balotelli should not have been racially abused by Juventus fans whilst playing for Inter Milan. This is thuggery, not football.

It is everybody’s responsibility that competitive and fiercely contested sport does not descend into bestiality. Violence in football can possess a variety of pretexts, but these cannot be used as justification for invoking carnage. Ugly scenes are unacceptable, unwelcome and threaten to scar our beautiful game.

What do you make of Anthony’s argument? Comment below, or tweet us @PalatiComment

Photo of Rangers and Celtic from Jim Easton on Flickr