Football authorities need to see sense about standing

by Rory Tingle

The Football Supporters’ Federation (FSF) have recently announced that twenty English league clubs have pledged their support for the re-introduction of standing areas at football grounds. I welcome this news unequivocally.

The introduction of standing areas would be overwhelmingly popular, with a recent FSF survey finding that nine out of ten supporters back the choice to sit or stand. Ultimately football clubs are businesses, and the rejection of such strong customer opinion would not be acceptable in any other industry.

As a football fan who regularly stands at games I am driven by the desire to support the team I love, and firmly believe that the provision of safe standing areas would greatly improve the often stale atmosphere at Premier League grounds.

It only takes a cursory glance at Premier League matches to notice the huge number of fans who currently stand up in seated areas, and these supporters deserve proper safe standing areas, allowing those who wish to stand to do so while stopping those who prefer to sit from worrying about having their view obscured. It would be beneficial for everyone.

We must not become complacent and assume that the Premier League will always retain its remarkable popularity at home and abroad.

Many opponents of standing mistakenly cite Hillsborough as a reason not to allow its introduction. However, the Taylor report primarily blamed overcrowding, stadium layout, and poor policing for the disaster, and neither proposed a ban on standing nor claimed it was inherently unsafe.

The statement released by the Premier League that “crowd management has improved as a result of all-seater stadiums being in place in the top two divisions in this country” is misleading. Although crowd management has improved since the decades of endemic hooliganism, this is not due to the abolition of standing areas but as a result of improved stewarding.

Indeed, the current arrangement with seating is not entirely safe itself, causing tension between supporters and stewards, and I have witnessed many cases in which police intervention has been necessary.

As a result, safe standing at football games can no longer be rejected by its opponents on the basis of safety fears. The claim of Jim Chalmers, the president of the Football Safety Officers Association, that “the design and control measures already exist for the provision of safe standing” is representative of wider support for this system amongst safety experts.

This support largely stems from the highly successful use of “rail seats” in the German leagues. This system, which incorporates a safety barrier and a flip down seat on every other row, has been proven to be safe. The seats can be locked in an upright position so that two rows of supporters can stand in between the barriers, reducing the danger of a crush.

Furthermore, the Premier League’s claim that introducing standing would reverse the trend of “more diverse crowds” since the introduction of all-seater stadia is also flawed. Seated areas would still be available, and the fact that ticket prices in standing areas are typically lower than in seated areas could result in an even more diverse supporter base.

The greater density of supporters would also increase ticket revenue and refreshment sales. Although rail seats are initially more expensive to install, unlike plastic seats they are virtually unbreakable, and the economic benefits of having up to 1.8 more fans than in a typical seated area would quickly outweigh any initial cost.

Thus, I cannot see any valid reason for opposing small-scale pilot test projects of safe standing in the Premier League. This system has a proven safety record in Germany, and is supported by numerous architects and safety experts, including several high profile politicians.

I perceive a wider issue here, which concerns the character of English league football as a game, and indeed a business, built on the dedication of supporters who expend vast amounts of money and time to follow their team. The discouragement of the most vocal elements of football supporters who almost uniformly choose to stand at games threatens the live entertainment value of English football.

We must not become complacent and assume that the Premier League will always retain its remarkable popularity at home and abroad. Those fans who choose to stand form the bedrock of the remarkable success of institutions such as the Premier League, and the political and sporting elite should not discount their opinions.