Food porn: our new shameless obsession

By Patrick Brennan

“I want to see pictures of people, not pictures of meals. It’s Facebook, not Foodbook.” This was the response when I asked my housemate to describe their reaction to a recent social media craze: taking photos of meals and sharing them with the wider world via social networking sites. ‘Food porn’, as the media has dubbed it, is probably something you’re very familiar with through the likes of Facebook, Twitter or Instagram. But would you think twice about joining in on it if you knew that you may well be endangering the jobs of the world’s top chefs?

538455_10150724399314110_685664109_9187971_122791743_n

This bizarre, hyperbolic question arises following a recent statement by French chef Gilles Goujon, who runs a three Michelin-starred restaurant in southern France. In it Goujon remarked that he considered this photography trend to be “poor etiquette”.

Goujon even went so far as to suggest that photograph of his dishes appearing on social network sites “take away the surprise, and a little bit of my intellectual property”.

Certainly there is a fine line to be drawn. Should one treat a fine restaurant like a museum, where photography is often forbidden outright, or is a meal yours to do with as you please? Is it one’s right to be able to photograph fine dining experiences, or merely a privilege?

Fellow chef Alexandre Gauthier certainly appears to harbour the latter view, as his restaurant’s menus include a “no cameras” icon. Whilst cameras are not banned from the establishment, Gauthier laments this fashion of photographing food instead of people.

“Before, they were pictures of family, grandmother, and now we take pictures of food… We tweet, we like, we respond to comments, and the dish is cold.”

This craze is not limited to restaurants. Going by my own Facebook newsfeed alone, it would appear that just as many of us enjoy posting pictures of our own creations, from humble curries and breakfasts, to gargantuan cakes and desserts. A friend studying Veterinary Medicine at Cambridge once posted photos of an impressive cake he had constructed – an anatomically correct representation of a canine digestive system – which weighed in at an artery-bending 47,000 calories.

“Before, they were pictures of family, grandmother, and now we take pictures of food… We tweet, we like, we respond to comments, and the dish is cold”

Keen to discover more on the student perception of ‘food porn’, I posed the same question as before – “what’s your reaction when you see a food photo on your Facebook feed” – to several second year Durham students. Responses were surprisingly varied. Whilst many students’ reactions were generally negative, describing the perpetrators as “show-offs” and remarking that they “really hate that kind of stuff”, others had a more positive view on the phenomenon. One student said “it’s okay if it tells me where you are or what you’re doing”, whilst another said her initial reaction to such photos was often “oh my god, I want your life”- although she then went on to add that mundane, everyday meals did not quality as ‘food porn’ in her eyes.

The overall opinion of the group was that what makes these pictures alluring is often the time and place of the snap, as opposed to the food itself. A picture of an exotic meal in an interesting country is something to be revered and envied, but a photo of your day-to-day lunch is boring and ignorable. The motivation behind this photo-sharing fad, it would appear, is simply to tell the world what an interesting time you are having, not just what food you are eating.

This tendency to flaunt your lifestyle through your food sheds light on a whole culture of unashamed “showing off” through photo-sharing. Just as an ‘Instagrammed’ meal might be dubbed ‘food porn’; a tweet from your Barcelona hotel room might be labelled ‘location porn’; a snap of your new iPhone 5 could be classed as ‘technology porn’. Indeed, Ellen DeGeneres’s recent Oscars selfie, featuring her posing in amongst several other Hollywood A-listers, could even be seen as ‘people porn’. One might even go so far as to label all photo-sharing through social media under the umbrella term ‘lifestyle porn’.

This tendency to flaunt your lifestyle through your food sheds light on a whole culture of unashamed “showing off” through photo-sharing

Maybe it is not so much the intellectual property theft, as the simple shamelessness of this trend that has led these top chefs to view ‘food porn’ in such a bad light. Perhaps eating at a fine restaurant has simply become another way to advertise your high quality of life to your social circle.

On the flipside, however, social networking offers massive free advertising potential. Vain it may be, but Food Porn provides a chance for thousands of people to see just how good your restaurant is – through the sepia-filtered eyes of countless Facebook friends. I say Messieurs Goujon and Gauthier should sit back, relax and embrace this new interconnected, social generation, whilst reaping the benefits. But they are also welcome to despair of our self-obsessed, narcissistic culture while they are at it.

Photograph: Naomi Ellis