Floodlit alcohol ban: what do students think?
By Oliver Jervis
A recent poll produced by Palatinate has revealed that 70% of students are unhappy with Durham University’s new restrictions on the possession of unlicensed alcohol at Floodlit Cup matches. The same number also believe that it has not improved the atmosphere at these fixtures.
Palatinate’s polling additionally uncovered a desire among the student body to still bring their own alcohol to floodlit matches, despite the presence of these fresh regulations. According to the questionnaire provided, 68% were in favour of breaching the rules in this fashion.
Those who had already done so were found to have largely acted with impunity, as 96% of those involved declared that they their unlicensed alcohol had not been discovered or dealt with whatsoever.
This is a blow for the University, who at the start of this academic year made permanent a regulation prohibiting the possession of unlicensed alcohol in and around Maiden Castle.
Such a decision was made following poor fan behaviour during Floodlit Cup matches in the 2021- 2022 academic year, which saw an outright spectator ban for students from University College, Hatfield College, and Van Mildert College.
For this academic year, students were indirectly informed by the University that they would only be allowed to possess alcohol purchased from Maiden Castle’s freshly renovated bar on the sport centre’s grounds. However, this decision was met with outrage from some corners of Durham student life.
The Junior Common Rooms of St Aidan’s and Grey College were among those to stage protests during their own Floodlit Cup matches. Many objected to the implications the enforcement of such restrictions would have, with banners claiming that the decision promoted a “toxic” drinking culture that put students at risk.
96% of those involved declared that they their unlicensed alcohol had not been discovered or dealt with whatsoever
St Aidan’s JCR President, Joseph Eaton also proposed that the regulations made some feel as though they were being “priced out” of attending Floodlit Cup matches. With the results of Palatinate’s poll, it appears that such sentiment has not dissipated after a term of enduring the new restrictions.
The protests may have wilted slightly; nevertheless, a feeling of frustration persists as students react to what seems to have been a limited and unweighted period of consultation before the pervasive implementation of these regulations.
At the time of Palatinate discovering the extension of these rules, Quentin Sloper, Director of Student Enrichment at Durham University, said: “The atmosphere created at College Floodlit fixtures is generally very positive and the behaviour of most of the spectators is outstanding.
“Nevertheless, we did have to address some issues last year, and this is one of a number of measures designed to help ensure the safety of staff and officials, and to raise the overall standards of spectator behaviour.”
A cloud of doubt is now set over whether this has truly been done for the better of student experience in Durham.
Analysis
Statistics, although helpful, can occasionally be flawed. Not always, but enough to cause doubt and create an urge to see what is happening with your own eyes. Numbers are important; however, experiences are integral.
Thus, the Palatinate Sport team attended the recent first round Floodlit Cup football match between University College and South College, which concluded in a comeback 2-1 victory for the latter. The atmosphere upon arrival was jubilant, yet rather muted in comparison to crowds present in past years.
Evidence of relatively heavy pre-drinking was abundant but not bordering on the dangerous. So far, so expected.
However, our first surprise came as the steward deployed for the night began parading along the spectators’ barrier. Adorned with an appropriate snood and hi-vis jacket, the attendant concerned duly questioned those around us as to whether they possessed any alcohol.
Subsequently, it was stated that no beverages were permitted on the premises. That was when the metaphorical alarm bells started ringing.
Change to the restrictions does not look likely
Eventually, when asked by Palatinate Sport what was meant by this declaration, the steward revealed that their employers had ordered that no drinks whatsoever – including from Maiden Castle’s purpose-built bar – were allowed onto the concourse.
No clear reasons were given for this prohibition, and the frustration on the faces of those who had planned to utilise this designated resource was evident. To make matters worse for spectators in attendance, the bar closed ahead of halftime.
As a result, all were left without a means by which to secure any drink from the local area after 9pm. This was so despite the match being held on a Wednesday, during which Maiden Castle had hosted several BUCS fixtures.
When asked by Palatinate Sport for their thoughts on the alcohol debacle, on anonymous fan stated: “Well, I wanted to drink (my drinks) during the match, but I ended up drinking them before the match outside the gates because (the steward) made me do that. Drinking during the match adds to the atmosphere and lots here have brought them in.
“I think (the restriction) is quite hostile. I would drink anyway. I’m either going to turn up with drinks and drink them during the match, or I’m going to turn up drunk. There’s either one option or the other.
“I didn’t know they were going to take our drinks away because I was told they weren’t going to do that but because of that it made me drink a lot before the match to prepare.”
Although statistics can sometimes paint a distorted picture, it appears that in this instance accuracy has succeeded. Fan frustration has not alleviated with time and one could dare to suggest that students are growing tired with a university which continues to ignore their interests for the sake of profitability and a sanitised image.
Whether the issue concerns accommodation prices or sport fixtures, adequate communication is almost certainly lacking. Change to the restrictions does not look likely, regardless.
Image: Oliver Jervis

