Possible flaws in security of the National Student Survey

By Harriet Line
Research has revealed that universities can pretend to be students in the National Student Survey (NSS), corrupting the results.
Students from Felix (Imperial College London’s Student Newspaper) and the Department of Computing (DoC) successfully gained student information from a DoC database in a project to determine whether methods are being used by universities to skew data.
To access the NSS, the student’s institution name, their student number and their day and month of birth, alongside the first initial and first four letters of their surname are required.
Some of this information is provided publicly on social networking sites, such as Facebook.
The security of the survey has been questioned due to the small amount of information needed to log in. False impersonation of students could be conducted, manipulating the results.
Although multiple attempts are allowed on the survey, only the first response is counted towards the final data, so prompt action by universities to answer the survey, before students could permanently alter the results, could be carried out undetected.
However, there is no evidence that this has occurred, either at Durham University or any other institution.
The NSS, conducted by market research organisation Ipsos MORI on behalf of the Higher Education Funding Council for England, is important for university rankings and is the most extensive satisfaction survey of its kind.
A Durham University student remarked that “I used league tables and student satisfaction surveys religiously to decide which university to go to.
“They are fundamental in ensuring the place is right for you, as if the majority of students are happy, then the chances are you will be too”.
Calls for a more rigorous security check have been proposed, yet this could deter students if the process becomes more complicated or time consuming.
However, problems with the NSS are rare, and cases of malpractice are isolated, as in 2008, when Kingston University was reportedly pressurising students to answer dishonestly to manipulate the results.
There is no suggestion that Durham University has ever attempted to manipulate the results of the NSS. The University consistently performs well in the survey, and is currently 13th in the table, with 90% of students satisfied in 2011.
Bridgwater College in Somerset currently tops the satisfaction table, with the highest percentage of content students (97%).
Durham colleges compete to achieve the highest participation in the survey, with contests determining which college has the highest satisfaction rate and the highest survey uptake.
The survey is open to all final-year students and can be completed now at www.thestudentsurvey.com.
