Film review: Saw V
TO SOME EXTENT one has to feel sorry for the director of Saw V, David Hackl, who, making his directorial debut (having only been the production designer on the previous Saw films) has been left with two pressing issues.
The first is how best to tie up the intimidating number of loose ends left by the thrilling but nonetheless convoluted Saw IV. The second is how to incorporate the recently deceased antagonist Jigsaw (Tobin Bell), a figure who essentially embodies the series and who is infamous for the gruesome but undeniably cunning traps he conceives for his unfortunate victims.
Having saved a young girl from Jigsaw, Detective Mark Hoffman (Costas Mandylor) is lauded for his efforts and returns home as the hero of the police force.
FBI Agent Strahm (Scott Patterson) however, recovering from a recent escape from what appears to have been one of Jigsaw’s inhumane traps, begins to suspect Hoffman’s role in assisting Jigsaw with his ruthless games, leading to a tense tale of cat and mouse between the two officers that more or less drives the film towards its macabre ending.
Running in parallel with this struggle is the story of five strangers who, having woken up in a sewer with booby trapped collars around their necks, are forced to face, in typical Saw fashion, a series of murderous challenges that ultimately offer the prospect of escape … but only if they can be overcome.
These premises leave Director David Hackl to relay Hoffman’s past association with Jigsaw to us in the form of a series of chilling flashbacks, and so much of the length of film is spent simply filling the gaps in the plot left open by previous entries. While this might be enlightening for the avid Saw fan as we see many of the past traps and events from new perspectives, tedium does start to set in as for much of the film we are essentially backtracking over what we have already seen in the series.
This is compounded by the twist at the end of the film which is neither as surprising nor revelatory as anything we have seen previously, and as such those expecting an electrifying turn of events (now effectively tradition for the series) may leave the cinema feeling somewhat cheated.
At least though, these flashbacks infuse the film with the presence of the late Jigsaw, and as ever Tobin Bell’s performance is sublime: capturing the cold, bloodied mindset of a man who, disturbingly, seems to feel that his murderous games are somehow justified. This performance is enough to recover any ground lost by the work of the other actors, which is admittedly weak in places.
Yet it is the traps in this film that prove to be its true saving grace. The five strangers trapped in the sewer (literally) pay with blood in their desire to overcome the challenges set before them and Hackl does a fine job of conveying their desperation and panic against the familiarly grim, claustrophobic backdrop.
Indeed for many it is purely for the visceral thrills that the Saw series warrants viewing and those looking solely for unadulterated gore in this film will undoubtedly be satisfied.
While the traps on offer do not quite live up to the infamously stomach-churning ‘rack’ of Saw III or the unprecedented brutality of the original film, there are certainly enough obscene moments here to satiate even the most blood-hungry of viewers (the opening scene involving a bladed pendulum is particularly memorable) – ensuring that this film, like the previous instalments, is definitely not one to watch with the family.
A solid sequel then, but perhaps one that exhibits the first signs of age for the franchise, and with the iconic villain Jigsaw now becoming increasingly out of the picture, one has to wonder how next Halloween’s grisly instalment will live up to the inventiveness of its predecessors.
