Fifty Shades of Dreadful?

By Lydia Cronin 

 

Fifty Shades of Grey is far from a work of great literature. A series whose titles are all virtually identical is usually reserved for a pre-teen audience, and the books are essentially just Twilight fanfiction that happened to find mass market popularity by cashing in on the rise of the eBook. It may not be well written and the characters frustratingly two-dimensional, but I still finished it in two days and enjoyed it for what is was – funny, light, and something to talk about. It has been hugely commercially successful and, for what it’s worth, brought taboo and hidden subjects into the public eye for which it does deserve some credit. Due to be released on Valentine’s Day, the film adaptation certainly isn’t going to win any awards for romantic film of the year but it does promise to be enjoyable and amusing if taken for the entertainment it is.

Image: Focus Features
Image: Focus Features

The subject matter of Fifty Shades has turned many readers off immediately, but drawn in many more. It seems rather Victorian to suggest that it is the risqué topic which renders it awful and not worth reading. Plenty of books we now see as ‘great’ have sexual themes and many that seem tame now, D. H Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover being a prime example, were shocking for their contemporaries. The trilogy is enjoyable enough for what it is and what it aims to be – escapist entertainment. I’m not suggesting canonisation, just not condemnation. While the genre that’s been dubbed ‘mummy porn’ is uncomfortable for some, there is no reason to shame a book that’s causing no harm and promoting openness and non-judgment on subjects more often kept in the dark.

Admittedly the books have also received criticism from the other side of the coin and in particular, for not portraying the world of BDSM accurately and fuelling misconceptions. However, the novels are designed to thrill not educate, and so trying to hold them to the standards of a sex-ed class seems ridiculous. While I agree that the issues of consent and personal control aren’t well handled, again, choosing to read a book is not synonymous with subscribing to its ethics and values.

Another issue with the series for the literary market is that it has seen such high sales, yet has little of what one would want from a traditionally well-written bestseller.  As much as it is painful to hear that the sales of Zoe ‘Zoella’ Sugg’s debut, ghost-written, cliché-ridden novel outstripped that of its better written competitors; reading and writing has never been about profit or sales. Surely, even if the first book you read and loved was poorly crafted, that does not mean that the love of reading it taught you won’t turn you on (no pun intended) to greater things. None of us got into books by diving straight into War and Peace, so if books like Fifty Shades spark an interest in literature, why not support it? If it gets more people reading then I think it’s a good thing.

Fifty Shades can be seen as a triumph of self-publishing; E.L James inspired others, primarily women, to publish ebooks independently. For example, Barbara Freethy has recently hit digital sales of 4.8 million units and Lisa Genova’s Still Alice has enjoyed both stage and screen adaptations and sales in 30 countries. This not only demonstrates to existing publishers the necessity of keeping up with the times in order to not be left behind in the wake of technological advancement, but also allows more to share their creative expression, and more readers to find their next favourite book. While this may not be the way the next Dickens will enter the world, it certainly widens the expanse of reading material, as well as ways to read. It’s well known that JK Rowling was repeatedly turned down by publishers, so maybe this seal of approval is far from necessary for a great read.

Beboi
Beboi

You may think that Fifty Shades is badly written and its story neither believable nor compelling and indeed it is often described as smutty, lowbrow, and repetitive. Nevertheless, there’s no call for snobbiness regarding what others find entertaining or what they choose to read. It has paved the way for alternative methods of marketing new writers, and encouraged a huge non-reading audience to pick up a book – an act which could never be seen as a negative.