Feminism: an outdated term?

By Sam Courtney-GuyComment

Feminism is an ideology: one that has gone through waves of resurgence and obscurity since its beginnings in the 18th Century. Now – in our Durham bubble especially – it has become a significant talking point. But feminism is an outdated term and will never be fully embraced by society.

This is not to say it’s not been of huge worth. A lot has been achieved for women (in the West, anyway): the right to vote, equality under the law, and the breakdown of taboos limiting what they can and can’t do with their lives. Nor is this to argue, as many loud and vociferous voices have, that feminism has somehow ‘won’. There’s plenty today that it hasn’t achieved. For example, there are still woefully few women in positions of power besides in a few token Scandinavian countries.We_Can_Do_It!

Feminism has arguably failed working class women, too: the pay gap between men and women; the differences in career opportunities; these are far smaller among the wealthy than the poor. Despite the victories in gender equality before the law, women are still more often seen as intellectually inferior, more often sexually objectified, and more often sidelined in important positions than men.

Anyone who sees gender equality as a past achievement is deluding themselves – but why is society like this? There is a whole sea of reasons for it, all connected and twisted together. But to explain why is far too complicated a task.

A more appropriate question to ask is this: why has feminism failed? There are some fairly simple observations to make here. Male inertia certainly hasn’t helped: since the dawn of the women’s equality movement, there have been men to resist it. There are still undoubtedly men who are overtly misogynist. But there are plenty who aren’t – plenty of men today either aren’t sexist, or aren’t consciously so. Cultural inertia explains the latter of those two: Western culture is littered with values that subtly undermine gender equality. These can also go some way to explaining why many women aren’t feminists. For example, the importance of family values causes animosity towards career-driven women, who are often seen as abandoning their children for selfish gain, whilst men are just ‘providing’.

So what does feminism lack that could solve all this? Looking at the masculine gender is a good starting point. There are plenty of ways in which society is loaded against men, too. Consider what being ‘manly’ means: men must be aggressive, selfish and often cold to succeed – what of those who don’t want to act this way? Masculinity is messily bound up with violence and aggression, even though most of us can agree these are not desirable or good ways to be. Men lose out because of this too: they spend 40% more time in prison, for the same sentences, than women, and when it comes to child custody cases the odds are heavily stacked against them.

Though, this is by no means to deny that women lose out far more when it comes to gender difference. The point of this is to show that we can all gain from shedding the mantle of gender responsibilities. On the whole, legal victories for equality causes throughout history have achieved by coercing or gaining concessions from the majority. Values can only change by being accepted by the majority, and this is where feminism has ground to a halt. It has associated itself too much with law and enforcement – legislation in the work place, red tape, and so on. Men don’t get involved in this partly because it offers no gain to them. Non-feminist women don’t partly because of the anxiety that abounds from non-conformity.

We have built values into gender, and we can only achieve equality by splitting the two apart. This is where feminism should step out. It is divisive: it pits men against women, and even women against women. Who knows what to call its replacement: as long as it’s about unity between men and women, it will result in equality between them too.

‘Image: We Can Do It’ by J. Howard Miller