Female conductors: it’s her time
By Theo Golden, Music Editor
This year, DUPO (one of the Durham orchestral societies) appointed their first female conductor, Sonia Bae, for their Chamber Orchestra. Yet, despite this success, it calls into question the diversity that Durham has on its podium.
DUPO has existed for over a decade and it is a society that sits alongside groups like DUOS and DUCE under the Music Durham umbrella. DUCE has never had a female conductor and DUOS hasn’t in at least over five years. Furthermore, both DUOS and DUPO have two conducting seats that come up every year, but despite this, a woman has never been given the opportunity.
Why, as Sonia Bae put it to me, is it a “new concept” for non-musicians and a “novelty” for musicians that a woman fills this role? This is due to the systemic neglect and suppression of female talent in music throughout history. When one is asked to imagine a conductor, it is hard not to think of a 60-year-old white man in a set of tails or of names such as Sir Simon Rattle or Ed Gardner.
The role of the conductor demands that one has extensive training, not only as a performer, but also as an academic. Thus, the historically limited access to further musical education and opportunities for women has traditionally all but barred the podium to women. To put this into perspective, the Berlin Philharmonic, arguably the best orchestra in the world, did not appoint a woman to a full-time instrumentalist position until 1982. Furthermore, the Vienna Philharmonic,, constantly marred by its politics, only had its first female conductor in 2005.
When I spoke to Sonia Bae, I asked her what continues to limit women from accessing these roles. She replied: “imposter syndrome”. Bae explained that she felt “over-powered” by “over-confident course mates”, and that she might not belong there as much as others. However, Sonia really isn’t one to be scared off, saying “I always wanted to know what its like to stand on a podium, and I was a shy fresher with ambition”. Yet, Sonia still felt that she had to “prove” that she “deserved it”.
Sonia said that social media helped her overcome the perception that there is “a direction that women should go”. Inspired by the likes of Alondra de la Parra, a fantastic female Mexican conductor, she felt empowered to pursue her goal. A few years ago she “would have tried to be more manly” when approaching the role, she said. However, conductors like the CBSO star Mirga GražinytėTyla showed that “being true to yourself” was best for the “orchestra all round”.
Why should we care? As with all diversity, it provides a different perspective and a new energy. The goal is that it be “normal” to have a female conductor; we need to highlight this issue until, as Bae put it, “music transcends the gender-divide”.
How can we get more female conductors?
Durham needs more exposure to “female conductors in talks and masterclasses”, Bae said. I would add that this must be realised at a younger age. If we intend to get more female talent, we need to engage with children and show that women belong on the podium.
Work is being done. Since Marin Alsop’s became the first women to conduct the Last Night of the Proms in 2013, some female appointments have been made, and the creation of a women-only course at Morley College. Yet in 2017, a study done by James Murphy of the Association of British Orchestras showed that only four of the over 100 conducting seats were filled by women.
One of the saddest parts of Sonia’s story is that she felt that she needed “a male-figurehead” to tell her that she “could do it”, and that because it came from a man it meant more. Bae says that it meant a huge amount to have “earn their respect as a conductor” but openly admits that this reality is “awful”. So, does this mean that even when women are succeeding in this field they are still not respected? Possibly despite there being female trailblazers, there are still not enough throughout the musical food chain, and therefore their success is still not completely tangible.
Bae also spoke of difficulties she faced being from a minority background, being spoken to as an “outsider” and feeling “isolated”. Music is a universal language, and contributions by all should be cherished and respected. We should be celebrating our diversity instead of having to call out the anomaly of a single female conductor.
Bae’s advice to budding female conductors is “don’t be so afraid, don’t think about what others will think. Just go for it!”. I can’t wait to see what Sonia’s future looks like, and I can only hope that more follow in her footsteps.
You can catch Sonia at her upcoming concert with DUPO Chamber on 29th November in Castle Great Hall.
Image by Theo Golden
