Faking it

by Katie Shuff

A harmless emulation of high fashion or a serious case of high theft, counterfeit fashion remains a contentious issue and it still has the ability to divide designers and consumers alike. Whilst most of us regard fake watches, sunglasses and handbags as innocent holiday splurges, authorities suggest that counterfeit fashion not only robs major fashion houses of serious revenue, but also fuels terrorism, organised crime and child labour. But is this really the case? Does the problem of counterfeit fashion question the whole ethos of high street fashion, an ultimate imitation of desirable runway pieces at a fraction of the price?

It would appear that even the authorities are undecided over this issue. Most recently Coach, a luxury American handbag and accessories label synonymous with Manhattan’s elite, was awarded a hundred and sixty million pounds in compensation for its losses as a result of Internet counterfeits. Furthermore, the lifestyle label was granted the right to shut down five hundred and seventy domain names linked to websites selling carbon copies of their most popular pieces. Alarmingly though, this sum of money, as the spokesperson for Coach described it, is only symbolic. Not surprisingly, it would prove impossible to locate all those running said illegal sites and seize their profits accordingly. This begs the question; is it really worth society’s time and effort sending authorities on a wild goose chase to find these criminals who are virtually impossible to catch and prosecute. As Professor David Wall, a fellow of Durham University puts it, “We should be focusing on the trade in counterfeit drugs, dodgy aircraft parts and other stuff that really causes public harm. At a time when there is no more public resources for police, and they are being asked to do more, law enforcement should be focusing on other things.”

However, Coach’s case is not unique in its bid to secure large sums of compensation. Both True Religion Apparel and UGG Australia received almost eight hundred and sixty four million dollars and six hundred and eighty six million dollars respectively as a way of making up, to some extent, the losses allegedly attributed to counterfeits. Furthermore, high end fashion houses such as Burberry and Hermes have also received counterfeit compensation. Contrary to popular belief, Professor Wall argues that brands actually benefit from counterfeit production in terms of speeding up the fashion cycle and increasing brand awareness. Notably, the influx of red-soled shoes on the high street has made Christian Louboutin a house hold name. However, one cannot help but feel a sudden pang of despair at the sight of an overtly brash pair of heels teamed with a chipped, slightly off red sole. A sentiment Louboutin felt all to strongly himself, causing him to trade mark his revered red soles in order to reduce the number of counterfeits. Consequently, twenty thousand pairs of fake Louboutins were seized by US border control in LA alone during the month of August.

This steady increase in the popularity of counterfeit fashion can be attributed to a number of factors. Firstly and perhaps most simply, the quality of fake goods has improved dramatically over the years, thus altering the previous stigma attached to buying carbon copies. Consequently, a new market has emerged amongst even the wealthiest circles, as well produced counterfeit goods are made available through private, word of mouth sales which aim to sell bags retailing for one thousand three hundred US dollars for only three hundred dollars. The rise in E-Commerce sites has also aided the availability and accessibility of counterfeit goods. Buyers no longer have to wait for their summer holidays before purchasing the latest fake fashions. What is perhaps surprising though is the slow speed in which fashion houses react to the production of counterfeit goods, maybe illustrating how losses attributed to counterfeits are grossly exaggerated. However, this is beginning to change as copies become even harder to spot, thus potentially reducing the designer’s clientele. Finally, as this article ventured to explore earlier on, attempts to pass charges against producers of fake goods prove difficult to follow through, with current monitoring systems failing to work adequately.

The line between fakery and flattery also transcends the high fashion to high street debate. Should high street brands such as H&M, Selfridges, and dare I say it, Topshop, be able to copy catwalk trends so crudely? For me, there needs to be balance. Of course high street brands should look to the main runway spectacles for inspiration and produce, to a certain extent, garments which resemble those seen in designer show rooms. Income should not affect a person’s ability to look or feel fashionable. The fact that designers are so willing to collaborate with high street brands, simply look to Christopher Kane, J. W Anderson and Versace to name but a few. But at the same time, there needs to be a certain edge, realism added to high fashion-inspired pieces which only a good high street shop can ascertain. Certain looks need to be adapted, moulded even, to fit the youthful criteria of high street fashion. Without this subtle twist, high street fashion will simply fall flat to the original designer version, which ultimately uses better materials and a higher degree of craftsmanship. That’s where Topshop succeeds for me, blending the key seasonal trends with that uniquely revered London street style. Somehow, its pieces always appear to be marching to their own drum, whilst incorporating subtle nods to their high fashion counterparts.

Whilst I am not for a single second condoning the sale of counterfeit fashion, it is after all illegal to sell fake goods and can lead to hefty fines for consumers who buy counterfeit pieces in certain countries, I am merely implying that the exclusivity designer houses strive desperately for could ultimately contribute to their downfall. The lack of accessibility pushes those fashion conscious consumers to extremes, so can designers really be surprised that the majority of buyers refuse to pay extortionate amounts of money for pieces which come and go out of fashion quickly? In an economically tight global climate, would money not be better spent on resolving more heinous crimes? And as for high street fashion, surely the revolving door of fashion makes Topshop and other less expensive go-to stores places where consumers can get their fashion fix –

Then again, I am but a student on a considerably restricted budget.

Photograph: The Epoch Times