The problem of government faith schools

by Nick Bradley

In September, the Al-Madinah School in Derby officially opened for the start of the academic year. It was the first Muslim faith school to be entirely funded by the Department of Education. On the school’s website it describes a strong Muslim ethos as a means of maximising the success of its pupils.

The school has caused controversy with the inclusion of an Islamic studies programme in the curriculum. Pupils will be taught Quran reading, translation and memorisation, and other Islamic doctrine. There will be an ‘opt-out’ clause, but the decision will lie with parents. Children as young as four, Islamic by an accident of birth, will be taught a distorted view of the world based upon a seventh century text.

The Derbyshire Secularists and Humanists group has described the school’s curriculum as “both doctrinal and confessional religious indoctrination.”

Members of the local Muslim community in Derby are also unhappy with the Al-Madinah School, complaining that the school is not Islamic enough. Kamran Raja, spokesperson for the opposition, said that the project was “a way of bringing independent Islamic education of children in Muslim communities under state control.”

He also said that it “will teach a secularised form of Islam, stripped of all rules and values, and reduced to a crude universal ethos and a few meaningless rituals.”

Perhaps it has been a shrewd move of the Government to fund a notably moderate Islamic faith school. It is not unthinkable that the Al-Madinah school is the first step towards a national effort to ‘secularise’ Islam, with the aim of reducing the faith to a predominantly cultural phenomenon, like British Christianity.

The headmaster, Andrew Cutts-Mckay, claims he wants children to grow up amongst different races and cultures, to learn to become part of a ‘multicultural’ society. Integrating Muslims with non-Muslims is surely better than segregation. The Al-Madinah School might actually take the ‘sting’ out of Islam.

The school’s website insists that it will teach “Islam in its true form which is interconnected with peace and love,” and the “true message of the Prophet Mohammed, which was about preserving with peaceful solutions and love for all human beings.” Whilst the accuracy of these statements is contestable, the school’s commitment to the teaching of peace and love cannot be criticised.

Children as young as four, Islamic by an accident of birth, will be taught a distorted view of the world based upon a seventh century text.

But can the Quran be reinterpreted so easily? It must not be forgotten that for Muslims, the Quran is the infallible word of Allah. It teaches, inter alia, that the penalty for apostasy is death and that women are inferior to men. Like Roman Catholicism, Islam is sexually repressive, and cannot, therefore, lead to peace. Like the Old Testament, the Quran teaches humans to fear a God they cannot see. It attempts to condition humans to become subordinates in a relationship with an invisible creator. This prescriptive enslavement bears a frightening resemblance to the traditional relationship between slave and master.

Other studies in the Al-Madinah School, particularly the sciences, will be undermined, even contradicted by the totalitarian information relayed to them in an early medieval text. At home, it is the right of Muslim families to teach their children what they like. But is it acceptable for tax-payers money to be spent on preaching the state religion of Saudi Arabia and Iran in British schools?

The question is not exclusively Islamic. In July of this year, the education secretary, Michael Gove, approved the opening of three fundamentalist Christian free schools in Sunderland.

Grindon Hall Christian School in Sunderland has released statements which say that evolution will be taught as a scientific principle to its pupils, but in another statement, Grindon Hall said that creationism will also be taught as a scientific theory. Is this good enough for any promoter of an enlightened society?

Regardless of the undeniable existence of a strong Christian identity in the UK, it would be absurd to argue that fundamentalist Christian schools are permissible, but Islamic schools are not. If intellectual cultivation is to take priority over religious devotion, the very concept of faith in schools must be scrutinized.

Ultimately, the sponsoring by the state of moderate and mixed Islamic faith schools such as Al-Madinah could lead to an embrace of British cultural values by the large number of Muslim communities in the UK.

Alternatively, it could lead to a generation of British Muslims who have been defined by the faith of their parents coerced into believing that the Quran is a ‘perfect’ book: a dangerous prospect.