Extinction Rebellion is here to stay – but it must adapt
By Kai Dattani
Extinction Rebellion isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. As political parties right across the spectrum gear up to tackle a climate emergency, be it offering a radical Green New Deal, or on a flatter, Conservative note, promising new green-coloured number plates, XR’s ability to disrupt and engage people, parties and businesses is crucial.
However, a movement which is both at the centre of political discourse and as well quite literally at the centre of the streets cannot avoid scrutiny, in spite of their noble cause. Therefore, it has to be asked whether XR is a genuine, bottom-up movement attacking the vested interests causing a climate emergency, or if it is instead a middle-class camping club for white vegetarians with too many Smiths songs on their Spotify playlists.
a middle-class camping club for white vegetarians with too many Smiths songs on their Spotify playlists.
Extinction Rebellion need to stick to activism nationwide and stay away from Newham. Many of the class and race-based criticisms of XR have come to light in the context of the movement’s choice to disrupt public transport in Canning Town, preventing largely working-class commuters in one of London’s poorest boroughs from their day to day activities.
This foolish and ineffective attack on those most likely to face the consequences of climate change throws into question whether the makeup of Extinction Rebellion is suitable for their cause and environment. XR has swanned into London, Barbour jacket-clad, carrying a rural, countryside-alliance aesthetic, reinforced by its key activists coming from rural and semi-rural areas.
Despite their cause being one shared by most Londoners, XR’s image and activism seems less and less concerned with tackling the neoliberalism in the Global North and the neo-colonialism in the Global South which is driving a climate emergency.
A Question Time appearance by Rupert Read, a key XR activist who has pointed to migration as a key cause of climate change, its protestors sending flowers to the historically institutionally racist Brixton police station and its occupation of Smithfield’s meat market have all shown the movement to be out of touch with the working class, multicultural London communities who have been victims to the same causes of the climate emergency that XR have been fighting against.
Extinction Rebellion are not ‘enemies of the people’. Despite what has been presented by some on the right, XR are probably not inherently classist or racist. At the heart of this disconnect between XR and the people is their idea that the environmental crisis is not political and exists beyond the social and racial inequalities that plague Britain.
This is idealistic, but simply untrue in reality. When it is clear that the most ethnically diverse and poorest communities will face the wrath of climate change, XR cannot continue without deep, integral involvement from these communities. However, how can it invite this sort of involvement when its key strategy is based around mass-arrest, something that affects people of colour to a far greater degree.
Its key strategy is based around mass-arrest, something that affects people of colour to a far greater degree.
XR seems to ignore the social consequences of neoliberalism in the name of intersectionality and appearing ‘beyond politics’. As populism across the West, be it Trump, Le Pen or the gilets jaunes, succeed in selling environmentalism as a movement for the elite, not the people, XR need to seek to change this, and position themselves as activists against the poverty, austerity and racial inequality that is very much tied in with the factors and structures causing a climate emergency.
The test of the future for the movement is based around its ability to escape being presented as a middle-class, doomsday cult, out of touch with the various issues facing common working people. Extinction Rebellion needs to pack away the circus skills and trance music, and embrace the very communities that share their frustrations with an economically and environmentally unjust system.
Photo credit: daniel james on Unsplash
