Extinction Rebellion: Elaborate but ineffective
Henry R. J. Warner
Unless you’ve been squirrelled away on Level 4 of the Billy B all holiday then you’ve probably heard of Extinction Rebellion. They’ve been hanging out on Waterloo Bridge and around Marble Arch and making lots of noise with their obnoxiously loud drums. Over a thousand of these so-called ‘rebels’ have been arrested and they’ve royally pissed off everyone. So what do they want and are they realistically going to get it?
They want us to move “beyond politics”
If you check out the well-designed Extinction Rebellion website what you find are three seemingly basic demands. They want everyone (especially governments) to “Tell the truth.” They want us to “Act now” by halting biodiversity loss and reducing greenhouse gas emissions to net zero by 2025. They want us to move “beyond politics” on climate and ecological issues by creating and empowering a Citizens’ Assembly to make decisions in this area. These are their demands, but what do they actually want?
These Extinction Rebellion people are worried, really worried.
They want us to “Act now” by reducing emissions by 2025
As a result of being so incredibly worried they’ve been banding about phrases like “climate emergency.” Essentially their message is, in slightly less ambiguous terms: we’re screwed and it’s our fault. In the eyes of the Extinction Rebel, humanity has, using the evil power of state capitalism, killed Mother Nature and doomed us all to… extinction.
If I’m going to be perfectly honest, I’m worried too. This is where the Extinction Rebellion people are right, climate change is a problem and it’s a problem that something ought to be done about. Their solution, if you can call it that, involves a lot of sweeping government re-intervention, the outlawing of fun and most nice things (imagine a world without air travel, lattes, and other vital aspects of modernity).
They’re looking at the causes of climate change without looking at the bigger picture. Climate change is a problem (well it’s actually a cluster of problems but we’ll get to that later) but it isn’t the only problem. If we are in a “Climate Emergency” then we’re also in a lot of other emergencies. If the best solution to climate change is basically immediately outlawing our species’ main energy source, then we should probably be more worried.
The emergency we are facing is an energy one
These so-called “rebels” have identified a problem (hitherto apparently unknown about) and have suggested pretty much exactly the same solution that has been unsuccessfully tried for global warming’s entire political lifetime. Yes, if you cut emissions down to zero and you managed to completely restructure government in a way that led to perfect climate decisions then Mother Nature would probably be okay. However, this isn’t going to happen. People need energy, and the cheaper they can get it the better. If you want to solve the problem of climate change you should look for a solution that is viable in the short, medium, and long term.
The emergency we are facing is not a climate one. The emergency we are facing is an energy one. If you think that green energy is the answer then stop trying to bubble wrap it. There is regulatory bubble wrap in-and-around the fossil-fuel sector as well as the green energy sector.
Wars are waged to secure oil reserves, subsidies warp the market creating false signals and allowing poor decisions to go uncorrected, intellectual property keeps the value of good ideas in the hands of the few rather than the many. If you want a greener future where energy is as if not more plentiful then turn you ire away from the reliance on our best energy technology and face it at those who stand in the way of our collective ability to create something better.
Photo: Mark Norton
