Exclusive interview with lecturer gives dark insight into hidden culture
Official Durham University figures show that the university employs very few women in senior professional posts and very few ethnic minorities.
The data, obtained by Palatinate through a Freedom of Information (FoI) request submitted to the University, shows that there are 71 women and 274 men at the highest pay grade of University employees.
Female employees decrease from 427 to 195 employees between pay grades seven and eight. The transition from grades seven to eight for men, on the other hand, goes from 449 to 301 employees. Theresa McKinven, Durham University and Colleges Union (DUCU) Equality Representative, provided Palatinate with a further breakdown of staff in terms of gender by department.
She said: “Only 27% of academic staff are female, 10% of Professors in Science are female, 22% of Professors in Arts and Humanities are female, and 37% of Professors in Social Sciences and Health are female.”
Figures are also conservative amongst the ethnic make-up of professional staff. The University has 1,937 white employees; the next largest ethnic group is Asian or Asian British – Indian, with 26 employees.
Explaining the statistics, Tom Ward, Pro-Vice-Chancellor for Education and Chair of the Disability and Equality Advisory Group, commented, “There is no single, simple answer to this.
“The sector as a whole has poor representation of women, and very poor representation of minority ethnic groups, in senior positions.”
Conversely, Theresa McKinven pointed out that the figures concerning gender cannot be attributed to academia in general, as their severity is amongst the worst of all British universities.
She said: “These numbers put Durham in the bottom 10% of UK universities for female academic staff, so it’s clear that the low numbers of women academics at Durham doesn’t simply reflect women being under-represented generally in academia, particularly at higher grades.”
Palatinate interviewed a Durham lecturer, who wishes to remain anonymous, for a first-hand explanation of the gender discrepancies.
Upon seeing the FoI data, the lecturer said: “The overall percentage [of female employees] is an embarrassment. The numbers make Durham look like a white, male University. And […] that’s certainly not how I would want Durham to be known.”
Part of the discordance in female to male staff, this lecturer explained, has to do with the lifestyle that accompanies being a Durham employee.
The lecturer spoke of tension in the University between supporting its staff and producing competitive research output, saying: “the Pro Vice-Chancellors and the Vice-Chancellor don’t really care about work/life balance, because ultimately, what they’re after is maintaining Durham’s prestige. So long as that is always a priority, everything else gets pushed aside.”
The lecturer added that “There’s a huge amount of pressure on junior scholars to produce a lot of work, and a lot of your work gets done outside of your office hours. Which means, if you have a family, when are you supposed to do it?”
Tom Ward also acknowledged the need for staff support at Durham, saying: “Durham will always be a very challenging place to work, because it is a hugely ambitious institution – but within that relentless ambition I hope we can provide […] a supportive and nurturing environment.”
However, the lecturer noted that “Durham does not have very generous maternity or paternity leave […] compared to other places. Obviously that’s then prejudicial to women.”
Another issue the lecturer identified was the dropping off of female employees from grades seven to eight: “I think the issue is quite complicated because there are so many factors that are involved – but in a sense it’s also very simple.
“There’s a high number of female lecturers in grade seven, and they’re starting to drop off at grade eight. That means they’re leaving, or that they’re not passing probation.”
Theresa McKinven had a different explanation for the drop off in women from grade seven to eight. She said, “The drop-off may represent the higher proportion of women in teaching or research only positions (often grade 7) where there is little possibility of promotion.
“Promotion from Teaching Fellow, to Senior Teaching Fellow to the equivalent of a Teaching Professor is very difficult and not all faculties support this as a career trajectory […]. Teaching Fellows are mostly grade 7 or 8 positions which indicates that many women have a very truncated career path.”
“However,” she added, “there are conflicting views on what the data means.”
Jenny James, DSU Education and Welfare Officer, told Palatinate that DUCU has gathered information on female employees at Durham and “they know of many women who have left and gone to other universities because they feel like their careers won’t be progressed here.”
In the interview, the lecturer asked “Why? What is going on with the internal hiring process that seems to be blatantly sexist?” The answer to that question is twofold. On the one hand, the evidence suggests that the people making hiring decisions tend not to prioritise gender equality. On the other hand, the process of promotion can be difficult: “The review process that goes with promotions can feel like a bullying process with unreasonable expectations.”
According to the DSU, the issue of staff diversity has been discussed on University Council. Tom Ward also stated that the “profile of equality and diversity is high in the University.”
Theresa McKinven also expressed a proactive stance towards the issue, saying, “DUCU welcomes the current focus on diversity and equality and the work being done to improve the present imbalance.”
The lecturer interviewed by Palatinate disagreed, and stated: “I don’t think the Vice-Chancellor is ever receptive to any comment that is critical towards Durham.
“I also think that part of it is that he [the Vice-Chancellor] is coming from the demographic that has benefitted from this sexist institutionalism. If the sexism is institutionalised, and you’re a part of the institution, it becomes very difficult to even see it.”
Theresa McKinven also implied that sexism is institutionalised at Durham, saying, “The gender and ethnicity imbalance is a symptom of a bigger, cultural problem which is both demonstrated and exacerbated by the lack of diversity at very senior levels.”
For instance, there is only one female staff member on Council out of seven staff members in total, and only one female head of department.
Asked about the lack of women in senior staff levels of the university, the anonymous lecturer stated that women are “smart” for not working these jobs.
“My experience,” the lecturer said, “has been that you do not want to get involved in the politics at the faculty level or above, because it’s a war. And part of that is going to mean that the people who are in those positions are going to be alpha males […] and if you’re not an alpha male, why would you want to be there?
“It’s kind of like the Margaret Thatcher situation. Is Thatcher an example of […] the victory of feminism? Well in one sense yes, because she’s the first woman Prime Minister, but in another sense absolutely not, because she did it by playing the rules of the male chauvinist game, and she didn’t do anything when she was there to actually alleviate the institutional sexism that prevailed. And I think that’s the same case here, that most women by choice wouldn’t be going into that bear pit because it’s a bear pit.”
Explaining the lack of women in the top tiers of the university, Tom Ward said “The position we are in is the end product of a great many processes, including a necessarily highly distributed appointment process, and wider social pressures.”
When asked what Durham is doing to address the gender imbalance in its staff, Tom Ward said that “Part of the progress here involves real culture change in the organisation, and attracting a wider applicant pool involves changing our reputation in the sector.”
However, data shows that the total number of applicants to professional University positions are nowhere near as lopsided as the numbers of those employed in higher level staff positions: women and men account for 34.5% and 52% of these applicants respectively (13.5% of applicants refused to state their gender).
Perhaps, then, what Durham needs is a “real culture change” if it is to improve its staff equality.
 Photograph: Durham Univeristy

