Everyone is to blame for the death of Lucy Meadows
Lucy Meadows, a transgender teacher, was found dead, presumably a result of suicide, on March 19th – barely three months since St. Mary Magdalen Primary School published a school bulletin announcing that Mr Nathan Upton would be returning as Miss Lucy Meadows.
Had local publications chosen not to leap upon the ‘story’, had Daily Mail reporters James Tozer and Nadia Parveen not seized upon it, and had columnist Richard Littlejohn not been allowed to pour his hateful bile on the matter (leading to a 100,000 petition calling for his removal), it is possible that Miss Meadows would be continuing to enjoy her teaching position, having achieved a decisive victory over the minority of individuals unwilling to even attempt to understand the teacher’s transition.
Littlejohn suggested that Meadows should have changed schools after the Christmas break to avoid ‘traumatising’ children’s ‘innocent’ minds – seemingly oblivious to the fact that she may have enjoyed her job, and that teaching positions cannot be changed at the flick of a finger or tap of an ignorant journalist’s keyboard. He wanted Lucy Meadows, for the sake of the children, not to exist. He should not be applauded for ‘handling the story sensitively’; the fact that he took it upon himself to make a member of the public’s private life the subject of a story for his miserable little column (whose past gems include ‘How to avoid airport security: wear a burka’) is pure sensationalist journalism at its worst. Anyone casting their eye across his archive will instantly identify it as a murky cesspit of racism, homophobia and sexism, and it needs to be drained as soon as possible. Richard Littlejohn may lose his livelihood, but a young woman has lost her life, and the consequences of his actions stretch beyond the tragic death of a brave young teacher.
By offering up Lucy Meadows as debate bait to the self-righteous public, he’s compromised the chances of acceptance for other transgender workers, especially by children and their parents. In a developed world barely out of apartheid, our focus should be on teaching children from an early age the value of acceptance, so that the next generation of minority ethnicities and religions, homosexuals and trans* individuals can grow up free of fear and social segregation. The onus should be on cultivating a society where individuals are no longer singled out as ‘different’, erasing the potential for bullying and isolation and bolstering equality of opportunity.
Unfortunately, this is an entirely unattainable goal until the press grow up. It seems almost inconceivable that people are still denied the right to an equal and unfettered life owing to nothing more than other people’s imaginary definitions of what state of being is socially acceptable. The omnipresent, all permeating press defines its own tightly controlled parameters of ‘normal’ and leap upon any exotic ‘others’ in a never-ending pantomime of scrutinisation and vilification – the Daily Mail is a perfect example, pouncing upon immigrants, welfare claimants, ‘gold diggers’ and anyone else who doesn’t fit their murderous choke hold of ‘Britishness’.
The tragic reality is that the children in question would have probably adapted to the new Miss Meadows in much the same way as receiving a differently coloured school pullover – knowing that it was the same garment but had changed slightly in a way that did not at all alter its meaning or its value. Only by mimicking adult prejudices would the children have been repulsed or ‘traumatised’ by the news that Nathan was now Lucy.
Lucy Meadows, like countless others, struggled with being born genetically male and took the decision to better her life, harming no-one. Tossing a vulnerable woman wilfully to the lions of national and international scrutiny is such an utterly morally decrepit and despicable act that one has to wonder if we are still living in the 1600s. The suicide rate for transgender individuals is around 70-80 times higher than their ‘normal’ counterparts, a statistic it seems unlikely a foaming bigot like Littlejohn would have cared to consider, or even been aware of – nor did he appear to have considered the impact his ‘outing’ had on Meadows’s two children.
Though the Daily Mail demonstrably have little regard for equality and diversity, they were so moved by Russell Brand and Jonathan Ross’s bullying of Andrew Sachs, they set up their own petition for their removal, and should demonstrate consistency by removing their own smug, arrogant bully – but they won’t. He is a bastion for an ever growing social sickness that objectifies and exploits human beings for others’ own titillation and gratification; he pulls in readers and he makes money.
Until we stop feeding this reckless machine, and take a step outside our socially-constructed bubble of normality, we are all responsible for the death of Lucy Meadows.
Photograph: SumOfUs

