Europe decrees controversial ‘right to be forgotten’
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has recently backed the “right to be forgotten.” This means that upon request individuals can have “inadequate, irrelevant, or no longer relevant data” removed from search results. Interestingly this does not remove the data from the websites containing it, but only the link to it in search results.
This ruling comes off the back of a case wherein a Spanish lawyer took Google to court because information of the repossession of his home in 1998 showed up in search results of his name, something which he felt unjustly negated his credibility.
In light of the decision from the European court, Google have created a simple form which can be filled in to request that links are removed from their search results, though as yet there is nothing similar from Bing or Yahoo.
The form states that certain users can request to have results from queries including their name removed from search results.
It goes on to say “we will assess each individual request and attempt to balance the privacy rights of the individual with the public’s right to know and distribute information.”
This means that the company can reject a takedown request if it deems the information to be of “public interest,” regardless of who is making the request.
Superficially the ruling seems like a good idea; no one really wants pictures of themselves in their teenage years cropping up in search results when they’re trying to find employment. But there is a bigger issue here, namely that we should have a right to know about certain people’s past.
Larry Page, co-founder and CEO of Google, said in an interview with the Financial Times, “I think it’s a question of the broad things you might value; there’s no way to get it perfect. There’s always going to be some harm. You can’t have perfect rights for everything.”
The company already has mechanisms for removing material related to child pornography and copyright infringement, so responses to take down requests are nothing new.
Page has also praised the court for trying to limit the information that can be removed to only include situations where people have a strong reason to object.
Many of the requests submitted so far have come from public figures trying to have embarrassing personal information removed from the search engine; Page believes that many of these will be unsuccessful. “Certainly, I worry about the effect that [placing limitations on publication] might have on democracy over time if we don’t do [it] perfectly.” But he agrees that “everyday people” have more right to suppress search links.
In addition to launching a formal process to comply with the European court’s ruling, Google has announced an advisory committee comprised of various free speech advocates, lawyers, and ethics professors. Jimmy Wales (founder of Wikipedia) has also agreed to sit on the committee.
In a recent interview he spoke out against the ruling. “In the case of truthful, non-defamatory information obtained legally, I think there is no possibility of any defensible ‘right’ to censor what other people are saying,” he said. “There is no ‘right to be forgotten’ – there is apparently a ‘right’ in Europe to censor some information that you don’t like.”
Javier Ruiz of the Open Rights Group believes that the ruling could pose a threat to free speech online. He said recently “we need to take into account individuals’ rights to privacy but if search engines are forced to remove links to legitimate content that is already in the public domain, but not the content itself, it could lead to online censorship.”
He highlights the fact that this goes against the opinion given by Advocate General of the ECJ, Niilo Jaaskinen, when he stated a year ago that Google should not be responsible for content published by third parties.
In light of the criticism that this ruling has come under, it seems certain that there will be significant change one way or the other as internet legislation stabilises.
Illustration: Carlos Luna and Palatinate

