EURO: Not out of the woods yet

by Isabella Grotto

german-and-eu-flag-flying_large

The New Year comes bearing bad news for the global economy. Little over three weeks into 2013 the IMF released its projection for growth in the coming year, and at 3.5% the figure appears 0.1% lower than last forecast in October.

The predictions resonate with findings from another global economic think-tank, the OECD, which downsized its forecast in its biannual Economic Outlook from 4.2% in May 2012 to 3.4% in October. Having grown from 3.2% in 2012, the global economy is still pulling itself out of the recession, but remains fragile and vulnerable to political crises, particularly in the Eurozone and US.

Addressing the World Economic Forum in Davos last month, the head of the IMF Christine Lagarde warned that 2013 would be a “make or break year for the global economy,” characterising the current recovery trend as “fragile and timid,” particularly because of its dependence on success in a politically and economically unstable Euro area. A further threat to the global economy comes from across the Atlantic, where excessive fiscal consolidation and over-zealous attacks on the US deficit could slow the world’s largest economy dangerously. With the Eurozone predicted to contract, and newly industrialised Asian economies set to grow less than previously hoped, America may find itself forced to shoulder much of the expectations for growth in the world’s advanced economies. To do so, it is vital that an agreement is reached between the Democrats and the Republicans in Congress, currently at loggerheads over fiscal policy plans.

Uncertainty and weakness in highly developed economies, expensive currencies for commodity exporters, and raised production costs are likely to mean growth in emergent markets will not return to 2010-2011 levels, the Fund also warned. Attention is now focused on the Eurozone and, increasingly, the US. In both areas, necessary policy-making efforts look dangerously beset by partisan conflict, and as the IMF revises its prediction from growth to contraction in the Eurozone, the need for reform appears more urgent than ever.

Continuing troubles in the old world

Among the causes for concern, therefore, the Eurozone remains significant. Policies aimed at strengthening the zone’s economy have failed to restore confidence and, despite somewhat easing financial conditions for governments and banks, have “not yet translated into improved borrowing conditions for the private sector,” according to the IMF’s report in January. The Fund lowered its growth forecast from 0.1% to -0.2%, predicting a contraction in the already beleaguered area, where propensity for political crises and slow-decision making do little to ease the minds of investors. Such weakness in policy-making powers is said to contribute to the view of the Eurozone as an unfinished project. With dangerous structural flaws making urgently needed policy action both difficult and slow to pass, confidence in the Euro venture continues to wane.

german-and-eu-flag-flying_largeAs some of the zone’s largest economies, including Italy, Spain and Greece, continue to struggle under a toxic combination of high levels of debt and sluggish growth, the deepening recession predicted by the IMF’s most recent figures have caused alarm within and outside the Euro area. The region is now seen as posing a “large downside risk” to the whole global economy, according to the Fund’s most recent report, and it is not difficult to trace the fall in predictions for global growth back to the dramatically revised outlook for the Eurozone.

However, though bleak, the current outlook is by far the worst scenario for the area. With the IMF still predicting positive, though slowed, growth for 2014, there is hope that the Eurozone is still en route to recovery. Nevertheless, this cautious optimism remains heavily reliant on union policy makers continuing their drive for reform and economic cooperation. If the current pressure on the weaker economies in the zone is loosened and reform efforts begin to slow, the Euro area may lose the impetus it needs to safely beat the recession once and for all. The IMF itself explicitly stated that if the current momentum for reform is not maintained, Europe could risk falling back into long-term stagnation, slowing the world economy down with it. Indeed, if the Euro-area crisis were to deepen this year, the UN estimates it would impact global growth at -0.3% in 2013, -0.7% in 2014 and up to -1.1% in 2015.

Walking the fiscal cliff

Since the start of the year, moreover, a new threat to the global economy has gained momentum, as the fiscal impasse between Democrats and Republicans in the United States continues to stray increasingly towards political brinkmanship. January 31st saw the passing of a long-awaited Congressional vote to extend the nation’s debt ceiling until May, a step that will no doubt assuage some of the most pressing concerns, but talks must continue if the US is to finally stave off the threat of combined spending cuts and tax hikes that would come into force were its economy allowed to fall into the so-called ‘fiscal cliff’. Having managed to avoid this fate at the end of the past year, the cuts were postponed for two months until March 1st, but the risk remains high.

Fiscal Cliff

Recently, the United Nations indicated the US fiscal deadlock as the biggest risk facing the global economy, followed by the eventualities of a slowing in China’s growth and a deepening of the Euro crisis. According to UN data, the possible impact on global growth of the US fiscal cliff is estimated at a staggering -1.2% in 2013, increasing to -2.1% in 2014 and -2.5% in 2015. Although a financial crisis is unlikely to be sparked, even in the event of the March deadline not heralding some agreement on savings, as it would be some time before the cuts were felt, the projected growth rates for the next three years stand testimony to the long-term impact that such a slowing of the world’s strongest economy could have.

Thus news of uncertainty in the US is likely to continue to cause concern world-wide. If it were to disprove its projection of leading western economy in the coming year, and not meet its predicted growth rate of 2%, its woes would be quick to echo through the world economy. This has the potential for seriously affecting growth in many developed countries, and all-importantly in China, the world’s second largest economy, where an economic slump would in turn add to the negative impact on the global economy.

The picture for the coming year, therefore, looks morose. The world awakens in 2013 to a new set of risks for the global economy, whose resolution appears far from certain. Lack of confidence in a receding EU on one hand, and deadlock in the US Congress over fiscal measures on the other, mean that the global economy is once again under serious threat in a moment when recovery is still weak and far from consolidated. By reflecting the unsure economic environment, the IMF revised growth rates caused widespread concern at the beginning of the year, and are likely to set a sombre tone for economic discourse and policy-making over the coming months.

However, the Fund’s message remained cautiously but determinedly optimistic, its report stressing that these figures still reflect an overall improvement in nearly all areas of the global economy (a conspicuous exception being the EU) and that although the world economy may be far from out of the woods, there is hope for recovery yet.