EU: In or Out?

By Joseph Baum

I’m a student at Durham University and I believe that politics matters. If there were a referendum tomorrow about our country’s membership of the European Union I honestly do not know how I would vote.

That is why the debate held by the Politics and International Relations Society on Thursday 26th February was so important. I do think we need a debate about Europe, not just to decide whether or not we are in or out of the European Union but to restore a sense that politics matters. Just 65% of the population voted at the last general election; last September almost 85% of the Scottish people voted in the referendum on independence.

Elections are supposed to tell us what government we want; referendums tell us what kind of nation we want to be. They are a great way to get our population, especially people of our age, involved in politics and we should embrace them at every opportunity. Most people who believe in democracy would accept that. The speakers at last Thursday’s debate disagreed, of course, on the issue itself.

Opponents of Britain’s membership of the European Union such as Nikki Sinclaire, misleadingly called “Eurosceptics”, have consistently identified a number of reasons why Britain should leave the European Union: it is too expensive, too wasteful, fundamentally undemocratic, threatens our national sovereignty and has left us unable to control our own borders.

I tend to agree with most of these points. That is not just based on an opinion. Recent figures by Migration Watch UK, an entirely independent and non-political organisation, have shown that England is now the second most densely populated country in Europe. At current levels we must build a home every seven minutes for the next 20 years to cope with the scale of immigration. It is a real and growing strain on our resources.

Of course we should welcome immigration. Where would we be without it? We would be far less culturally and ethnically diverse, less outward-looking as a society, less talented as a workforce and perhaps poorer for it as well. Concern about immigration is not the same as saying no to immigration. Eurosceptics seem to be saying yes to control. Yes to a system that knows how many people are coming in as well as out, how many homes we need to build, how many school places we need to provide. In short it seems sensible.

Of course we shouldn’t blame immigrants for many of the issues that our country faces – the government must also play its part. Lord Liddle argued last Thursday that perhaps part of the problem is that we simply aren’t building enough homes. Cuts to the Education budget, though necessary, are affecting a parent’s choice to send their child to the school that they want. That is almost certainly true, but it is an answer to a different question.

Other supporters of Britain’s membership of the European Union rightly point to the fact that Britain’s influence in the world is stronger within a family of nations rather than outside of it. But such organisations already exist. It is important to remember what our membership of the European Union means compared to what our membership of other institutions, NATO or the United Nations, does not.

The consequences of a centralised European Union on our national sovereignty is a lively and well covered subject. The direction of travel experienced since the Maastricht Treaty, the establishment of a European Parliament, a common currency and the rapid inclusion of former communist states has meant that many have become wary about what might happen next. Could it be a shared army? Or even a shared head of state?

To many the challenges the European Union presents are outweighed by the challenges that our country would face if we were to isolate ourselves from the rest of Europe. To others the European Union we are members of today is very different from the one we agreed to join 40 years ago. It is not about trade anymore, or even about politics. It is about people. The people who do not wish to be part of a political union.

To me it is about the people who have never had a say. I have never voted in a general election, nor have any of my fellow students under the age of 22. No one under the age of 58, however, has ever had a say on our membership of the European Union. It is time we did. Regardless of whether we are for or against our membership of the European Union surely we are all in favour of democracy. We should embrace the opportunity to participate when it arises and in the mean time, let’s go on having the debate. Thank you to Lord Liddle and Nikki Sinclaire for being a part of that debate.

European Union

 

Photograph: Pixabay