ESGs? Superficial greenwashing or effective corporate response to climate change?
By Emilia O’Keeffe
The threat of climate change is immense. The inextricable link between anthropogenic activity and the changing climate calls for urgent action if we are to preserve our environment and continue with life as we know it today. Although individuals can make small, localised changes to everyday life, for climate change to be holistically mitigated, larger bodies of influence like governments and private corporations, must do more to manage their widespread, unsustainable practices.
Historically crisis mitigation has been delegated to central government. However, the prevalence of neoliberalism in the 1990s enhanced the relative financial, and subsequently political, influence of private corporations, often rivalling state power. The trend of reduced state intervention and relaxation of financial regulation granted the private sector enhanced freedom to act beyond national boundaries, weakening state jurisdiction over their practices. As these corporations are not officially political bodies, they are not required to take personal action in same way as the public sector. This neoliberal political background has generated a culture of limited corporate social responsibility, with firms stereotypically primarily focused on profit margins, regardless of their social and environmental impact.
Long-term investments are the primary example of the financial sector’s response to climate change.
For the climate emergency to be thoroughly mitigated, the public and private sector need to work in tandem to reduce their impact on the environment, a concept relatively unique to contemporary crises. Governments are actively addressing climate change, taking legal action both nationally and internationally to mitigate against environmental degradation. Although more is being done by private corporations to address the climate emergency, their response does not mirror the magnitude of their contribution to climate change. This article will assess the efficacy of the private sectors’ financial response to the climate emergency. Are corporations effectively mitigating against climate change or is their response merely a marketing venture, implementing superficial environmental policies with the sole intention of gaining public support?
Long-term investments are the primary example of the financial sector’s response to climate change. This involves investors examining non-financial ESG factors details to identify risks and potential growth opportunities. ESG stands for ‘environment’, ‘social’ and ‘governance’, with climate change falling under the ‘E’. Long-term investments are then made within industries which perform well on ESG metrics. Accounting for these non-financial aspects has increased investments in sustainable practices, with renewable energy now dominating investment in the energy industry. There has been a surge in interest in sustainable investment, particularly following Covid-19 which highlighted the instability of financial markets and the need for the private sector to fund more sustainable practices.
ESG investments appear an effective corporate response to climate change. Long-term investments generate the sustainable foundations required to stimulate an increasingly green economy. Research has shown that long-term investments generate greater profit, evidenced by the multi-national corporation, 3M, saving $2.2 billion since introducing their ‘Pollution Prevention Pays’ program in 1975. With values and morals also becoming a greater consideration when investing, corporations committed to ESG investing have been shown to enhance their attractiveness to the public, generating further revenue. The financial and commercial incentive for private equity firms to enhance long-term sustainable investments has the potential to drive an effective corporate response to climate change. However, economically driven ulterior motives bode the question, how genuine is this response? Are ESG investments a thorough and sustainable corporate solution to climate change or do they represent superficial, ‘green-washed’ policies, paradoxically further contributing to the crisis?
For climate change to be mitigated with appropriate rigour and urgency, the current climate response requires significant change
Arguably, the rapid growth in long-term investments is merely a response to increased corporate transparency, with technological and media advancements improving insight into commercial practices. The lack of disclosure of actual monetary commitments to ESG factors, supports the argument that corporations are superficially addressing climate change. As companies are not required to disclose their actual monetary contribution sustainable investing, unlike the public sector, many private equity firms claim to make investments without revealing the extent of their actual commitment.
This suggests the growth in sustainable investing is a response to increased social concern over climate change, rather than a genuine personal commitment to the cause. Corporations often focus on the ‘G’ when assessing non-financial ESG factors, suggesting they are more concerned with the failure to comply to laws and enduring financial penalties than mitigating against climate change. The clear economic motivation and limited monetary disclosure, brings the legitimacy of this climate response into question.
Although presently ESG investing conceptually is flawed, it has potential to drive a thorough response to climate change. Some environmental NGOs, notably the ‘Climate Group’, have branded these sustainable investments counterintuitive as they increase distrust and undermine the necessary urgency of climate action. However, the surge of interest in financial sustainability undeniably marks a step in the right direction. Furthermore, in the United States, the Biden administration has called for better global guidelines and standardisation around ESG disclosure. Historically governments have done little to address ESG investments, denouncing it as a private sector issue but Mr Biden’s crack-down on superficial corporate ‘green’ policies marks a shift in environmental policy.
For climate change to be mitigated with appropriate rigour and urgency, the current climate response requires significant change. A systemic shift in neoliberal governance and corporate practice is fundamental for the climate emergency to be holistically addressed. This should be led by a comprehensive combined public-private sector response. Although the private sector’s response to climate change presently appears superficial, an optimist would regard the rapid growth in public and private interest in ESG investments as a break with the past, with the potential to induce the necessary systemic shift in climate change response.
Image credit: Visible Hand via Creative Commons.

