Equus Asinus: Men I Trust Album Review

By Charlotte Aspden

“Early in the writing and recording process,” the band wrote, “we realized we had a collection of songs with distinct energies yet equally meaningful to us. It became clear that we wanted to release them as two separate entities both from the same genus: Equus Asinus and Equus Caballus.”

Men I Trust, known for their breakthrough dream-pop hit ‘Show Me How’, have recently unveiled the first of their two interconnected equine-inspired albums this spring. Released on the 19th of March 2025, Equus Asinus marks the fifth independent studio album from the Montreal indie band. Consisting of Emmanuelle Proulx on lead vocals and guitar, Jessy Caron on guitar and bass and Dragos Chiriac on keyboards, Equus Asinus is a mix of classic Men I Trust with greater experimentation. Mellow is Men I Trusts’ middle name, with this album being no different. The title itself, meaning ‘Donkey’, hints at the leisurely, balmy pacing of the tracks, plodding along. Far from monotonous or dragging, Equus Asinus flows with a heavier-than-expected emotional load that is pulverised by the soothing folk, acoustic elements of the record, signalling a shift in their sonic palette towards a more profoundly melancholic sound in the band’s discography.

Men I Trust, known for their breakthrough dream-pop hit ‘Show Me How’, have recently unveiled the first of their two interconnected equine-inspired albums this spring’

Take the opening track, ‘I Come With Mud.’ What starts as an eerie tuning of guitars, quickly melts into smooth guitar riffs reminiscent of a nostalgic country-esque twang. This whole track feels like a sonic departure until Emma’s trademark vocals transition in and immediately, we’re back to recognisable Men I Trust once more: pared-back instrumentals and soft, heady lyricism which combine into a cocktail of velvety sonic success. The core sentiment evoked from Men I Trust is a feeling for nostalgia for a time that you never lived, with the cover art being no different. A 70s-inspired sepia vignette, where a man with questionable Dahmer-style glasses irons his shirt whilst a woman gazes pensively in the background, is shrouded in a grainy haze akin to their dream-pop aesthetic. Shot by the iconic Donna Ferrato- a feminist, internationally renowned documentary photographer- the fly-on-the-wall shot perfectly captures domestic mundanity with a grainy allure that echoes the more introspective tone of the record. 

not emptiness, but rather an air of uncertainty and yearning dominate – like fragmented memories struggling to resurface

Yet in their honeyed, rich melodies, certain tracks like ‘Frost Bite’ and ‘The Landkeeper’ pivot to a more haunting, wistful atmosphere. Whilst previous Men I Trust tracks have leaned into concentrated melancholic tones, here, in this album, the stark absence of their signature deep bass lines creates a palpable sense of distance; not emptiness, but rather an air of uncertainty and yearning dominate – like fragmented memories struggling to resurface. In ‘The Landkeeper,’ the band masterfully manipulates silence and space, using syncopated pauses in their lyrics to mirror the hypnotic ebb and flow of such emotion. ‘What Matters Most’, a jazzy piano solo against a light snare-drum, is a comforting, familiar end to the album, steeped in oneiric silky groove. Some fans may be disappointed that the album doesn’t demonstrate a drastic departure from their established resonances, focusing instead on refining their atmospheric allure. As anticipation builds for the second installment, Equus Caballus, where I predict it will harness a more upbeat, if unpredictable/wild, sound against a distinct emotional landscape, fans of the band will have no trouble seeing them perform live this year. They will commence a huge North America tour spanning three months this summer, followed by European dates in October, featuring Liana Flores as support.

Image Credit: Album Cover by Donna Ferrato