England goes back to the future with Moores appointment
By Matthew Lavender

One of those who clearly does not, however, is Peter Moores who, after five years in the shadows, has once more stepped into the blinding spotlight that is the position of England’s head coach.
After a calamitous winter in which England stumbled helplessly from one embarrassing catastrophe to another; Moores, who led England from 2007 to 2009 before an infamous falling-out with then-captain Kevin Pietersen led to his departure, has been charged with the exigent task of picking up the pieces and turning England into a force to be reckoned with on the international stage.
Moores is a man held in great esteem in the corridors of power at the ECB and has many qualities that make him a sound and rational choice, from his unquestionable enthusiasm and energy for coaching to his calm and level-headed demeanour.
In spite of this, however, Moores does appear a bizarre choice. The entire appointment has an air of redemption about it, as much for the ECB’s self-esteem as for Moores himself. The men at the top seem desperate to give Moores the chance not just to prove himself, but to prove that their faith in him – which was unmistakably public and which has remained unerring despite the ugly end to his first tenure- was completely justified. They are desperate for Moores’ second coming to yield the prosperity they had hoped he would bring in 2007, as much to verify their own belief in him as anything else.
But, far from putting them to bed, Moores’ appointment simply brings forward, once again, questions that surfaced during his first tenure that have yet to be answered, meaning reservations about his leadership may be necessary.
He, as previously mentioned, undoubtedly possesses many commendable qualities as a coach, but he is far from devoid of shortcomings. Chief amongst these is his energetic manner which, while popular with some players, has been felt by others in the past to be excessively over-bearing and intrusive. Indeed, this vice is widely felt to have to been the catalyst for the problems that led to his argument with Pietersen.
A key question that remains is whether Moores is capable of managing senior international cricketers who may possess significantly larger egos than those in county cricket, with the appropriate balance of attention and distance required. He failed to do this in his first spell in charge, and it is imperative that he does not repeat his mistake.
He will, of course, be helped by the absence of senior players within the present England set-up. The recent departure of Pietersen, Jonathan Trott, Graeme Swann and Matt Prior has left the side with few truly ‘senior’ players. Nevertheless, he must work out a way to successfully manage international cricketers while maintaining his trademark enthusiasm. Whether he can actually do this remains a question open to much deliberation.
The ECB’s untarnished fondness of Moores has undoubtedly secured him his second chance, but there remains an element of the contradictory about their decision to appoint him.
They have talked, at great length and with great conviction of the need for a fresh start after a disastrous winter and of the need for fresh blood and ideas to replace the ever-aging approach of the old regime. It is for this reason, let us not forget, that Kevin Pietersen has been relieved of his England duties.
However, despite their calls for a fresh approach and the starting of a new chapter, the ECB has chosen to pick a man from the past. Peter Moores, while undoubtedly someone with unfinished business at international level, is a man who is far from a fresh face, but a relic of the past.
While many will argue, some with great fervour, that this is not a hindrance to progression but a means by which it can be facilitated, there does seem to be an odd irony that Moores’ appointment runs counter to their previous rhetoric of originality.
Whether Moores can bury the ghosts of his past remains to be seen and it will be some time before any conclusive answer can be given to this intriguing question. One thing that is for sure, though, is that English cricket is moving into a new era, and Peter Moores is the man who has been chosen to lead them into it. It is now up to him to prove that, sometimes, “they” are wrong and that you are, in fact, right to go back.
