Energy security: beyond the headlines
At the end of the 1980s the UK was the first liberalized energy market, and now once more offers innovative market solutions.
Liberal energy policy has produced many success stories, such as a significant reduction in initial cost and the de-monopolization of the sector. Consumers also gained access to cheaper fuel and energy. Then the UK served as a model for the policies pursued at EU level.
However, with the growing uncertainty in the global energy markets, which was accompanied by the depletion of oil and gas deposits in the North Sea, the UK faces a relatively new challenge – the threat of security of supply, which have collided with the increasing importance of measures to contain climate change.
The market model did not deal with such challenges, and has led to the call for reform.
There was indeed also a change of priorities – the primacy of competition and low prices has been replaced by the priority for ensuring security of supply and the transformation towards a low-carbon economy.
New targets are included in the so-called Climate Change Act (2008), and in following years, the British government presented various elements in detail of the new approach (such as the reform of the electricity market, the ‘Green Deal program’).
This leads to questions as to who should pay for the much needed investments necessary to fulfil the goals laid out – the market (i.e. consumers) or the Government (i.e. the tax payer ergo the consumer).
Security of supply
The gas and oil resources in the North Sea provided secure and continuous energy supplies to the UK until the end of the 1990s.
However, since 2012, gas production has fallen by 60% compared to the record level in 2000 (from 108 to 41 billion m³), and oil production fell by 67 % (from 137 to 45 million tons).
The depletion of domestic deposits, transforming the UK into a net importer (in 2005) imposed the priority on the British government, contained in the Energy Security Strategy of 2012, to minimize the risks of excessive dependence on imports and diversification of supply, given the UK energy mix of 44% gas and 29% coal.
The dependency of the United Kingdom on the international oil and gas markets is set to reduce by increasing the national capacity of renewable, nuclear and non-conventional energy sources. It is also worth noting that the foreseen gas extraction from shale will benefit from very generous incentives (in the form of tax exemptions) for domestic shale industry in the United Kingdom. The UK also intends to source Liquefied Natural Gas from the United States.
Security concerns should be raised about the supply of aging energy assets. By 2020, one-fifth of the electricity plants will be closed, and thus significantly increase the risk of blackouts in the UK.
Without market support, mechanisms will not be in a position to ensure security of supply, hence the desire to reform the sector.
Announced on June 27th 2013 the reform of the energy market is currently at the centre of public debate in the United Kingdom.
There are two major elements: differential contracts (Contracts for Difference) and market power (Capacity Market). The first is to stabilize revenue, the other – to encourage investment, and encouraged low-carbon sources.
What next?
In response to the shortcomings of the market mechanism, the Government has proposed a shift in energy policy.
The change is to move away from the primacy of the market, which for many years formed the basis of British energy policy – recognizing that market forces are not able to ensure continuity of supply, decarbonisation of the economy and public services.
While the government is determined to achieve economic decarbonisation, the main challenge will be to find a balance between the fight against climate change and the maintenance of economic growth and competitiveness.
In the context of Europe, the UK with its ambitious goals is undoubtedly a strong supporter of EU climate policy. This will mean support for the increase in CO2 emissions reduction targets for 2030 and to maintain the role of ETS emissions.
On the other hand, the approach of the UK points to new trends in the EU – for action at the national, rather than European level.
The result of the British policy will be to increase state intervention in the energy sector and to support national projects. In the EU, it may be considered a violation of the principles of free trade, competition, and the single energy market. Therefore, the Commission will closely monitor the British reform. The first assessment can be formulated as early as this year as part of the guidelines for the support renewable energy and power generation.
Photographs: Marcel Oosterwijk/Quinn Dombrowski

