Emma (2020): the newest member of the Austen adaptation hall of fame

By Lily Riley

Being an avid Janeite myself, I sat in the cinema with my arms crossed and my eyebrow raised ready to be disappointed by the new adaptation of Austen’s Emma. Surely it couldn’t rival the BBC’s 2009 attempt. My disappointment was disappointed. The opening scenes made it very clear to me that I was to unfold my arms and simply bask in the beauty of Autumn de Wilde’s directorial debut as one of my most treasured books was brought to life in a fresh and delightfully comic way. 

Being primarily known for directing music videos, de Wilde took on an ambitious project in adapting the work of such a beloved author yet she does so with style and panache. Staying true to original dialogue, de Wilde captures the tone of Austen’s narrative perfectly. We initially meet an Emma that grates on the nerves, wearing her haughty derision like a badge of honour. Anya Taylor-Joy truly embodies the Miss Woodhouse that has ‘a disposition to think a little too well of herself.’ She is initially impetuous, disdainful and, if we’re being honest, slightly irritating. But then, she is supposed to be. Austen herself said that, in writing Emma, she set out to create ‘a heroine whom no-one but myself will much like.’ Taylor-Joy excels in this regard, making her eventual maturation all the more satisfying.  

Surrounding Taylor-Joy is an ensemble that so befit their characters, it seems as if they have been fan-cast. Bill Nighy and Miranda Hart make the perfect slapstick duo; Nighy in particular playing up to the ‘valetudinarian’ nature of Mr. Woodhouse, mentioning the presence of a draught as frequently as an ‘um’ in stilted conversation. For me, however, it was Miranda who stole the show: equal parts social unawareness and the loneliness of the human condition, she provokes tears as often as laughter. The scene on Box-Hill is all too familiar for many as Hart evokes what it is like to be singled out among company who validate already-present feelings of imposter syndrome. Johnny Flynn as Mr. George Knightley succeeds in embodying the ‘sensible man’ by whom Emma is guided and what he lacks in age he makes up for in emotional maturity, perhaps making the union slightly more palatable for a modern audience far more concerned with age gaps than the marriage-happy Georgians. My viewing companions and I did however lament the fact that no one thought to take a brush to his unruly mop: I’m sure Mr Knightley would not have approved of such a surfer-dude-do given his misgivings about everything else.  

Flynn does not just contribute visually to the film but also partook of the Original Soundtrack composed by Isobel Waller-Bridge (sister to Phoebe Waller-Bridge of Fleabag fame) and David Schweitzer. Flynn’s song ‘Queen Bee’ adds to the roster of folksy orchestral music which includes the likes of The Watersons. The score accompanies each character perfectly, satirizing the ridiculous Mr Elton with operatic soprano where Frank Churchill is introduced with a suave strings piece.  

One of the most attractive elements of de Wilde’s adaptation, however, is the set design. Filmed in the beautiful grounds of Firle Place, the set is a feast for the eyes (and the Pinterest board for interior design lovers), creating a pastel-paradise of epic proportions. In an interview with Architectural Digest, production designer Kave Quinn and set decorator Stella Fox reveal that the set was intended to mimic a doll’s house in which Emma can enact her well-meaning machinations. Fox told AD she wanted Emma’s bedroom in particular ‘to feel like an Italian ice cream.’ Now that she mentions it, the room does have a certain Neopolitanness about it.  

Whether you’re a fan of Jane Austen or just want to see Bill Nighy, well, being Bill Nighy, this film delivers a packet of pastel-toned joy. De Wilde’s debut is an indisputable success, especially for those of us who delight in the details. She creates self-referential parallels, such as the final reiteration of Elton’s initial sermon, to illustrate the narrative progression; the film feels complete, nonsense (or ‘NO-sense’ in Mr Elton’s words) becomes heart-warming romance, and children become adults. Emma added a little colour and a lot of laughs to my somewhat dystopian reality, as it takes on the word of England’s bardess and makes it new. 

Image: Unsplash