Embracing the Pseudo-human

By Pippa Lewin

The modern world appears to breed inauthenticity. Social media feeds are endless ‘aesthetic’ posts: an annotated, highlighted, underlined page of a book is posted, captioned “#book #reading #obsessed”. Someone is spotted reading philosophy on a park bench or during their morning commute. They’re disingenuous, poseurs, pseudo-intellectuals, fakes. Putting on a show. Modernity places a camera in every pocket, and the potential audience with each public venture grows ever larger, implicating the private sphere in this constant performance. Here arises the problem of ‘Schrödinger’s intellectual’. If real readers can only be confirmed by their unobserved actions, and any public attempt to prove one’s status marks them as ungenuine, how can you measure authenticity? In being asked: “Do you read Nietzsche?” One is inclined to fib in the moment, then read Nietzsche in preparation for impressing future interactions. (However, a quiz on how many members of a particular band they know may put them off future interactions altogether.) This is how a reader of Nietzsche is made. They desire, they pretend, they become, promoting a faux transformation. The inauthentic does not simply inspire the authentic, it is the authentic. Authenticity is inseparable from the idea that there is an accessible true and natural self, hiding out of habit under years of imperfect, corrupting socialisation. A scratch at the surface revealing a better, purer, more unique soul. A you before you. It has followed that a sure-fire remedy in ‘finding yourself’ is to break from the constant audience.

The inauthentic does not simply inspire the authentic, it is the authentic

To reconnect with nature, definitionally untouched, clean and true. Urban infrastructural endeavours to facilitate this link, however, are thoroughly unnatural. London gardens are divided into neat squares, each identical to the next. With imported and plastic grasses, peered on and shaded by imposing neighbouring houses, these green patches are totally implicated in the hands of man. We schedule moments of artificial escapism here, placing them in a spatial-temporal field inaccessible to the fallacious ‘true’ human. Our pseudo-selves are necessarily embodied and built into these attempts. Synonymising ‘unnatural’ and ‘man-made’ has led to the false conclusion that the socially constructed drives us further from a truer self. The eternal pressure of your neighbour’s gaze pushes some from the urban centre entirely. Hermetic ventures into the forest or country do not purify, as they are not a break from society at all. It is society that brought them there, that sustains them; it is them. ‘Touching grass’ isn’t a rejection of the social, but a reorientation of focus. As society came from nature, and you come from society, you will always approach nature with a social face, hands, and heart. It will smile, wave, and thrum to a familiar beat.

Hermetic ventures into the forest or country do not purify, as they are not a break from society at all

Our attempts to disentangle ourselves from society only pull us deeper into its web. Critically reflect on your place there, but do not feebly attempt to remove yourself from it. The distinctions of artificial and natural, inauthentic and authentic are false. We are necessarily social creatures, born without choice into a wholly social world, and made by it. A call to completely shed prejudice, culture, and society is a call to become inauthentic, unnatural and entirely un-human. It is a performance to read in public, but this is not unnatural, strange or embarrassing. To be a pseudo-human is to be as human as they come.

Image: weesam2010 via Flickr