Elitism in the English game: why does the Premier League have such few English managers?
By Dylan Chetcuti
Following the departure of Sean Dyche from Everton, the Premier League has been left with just two English managers, Newcastle’s Eddie Howe and recent West Ham appointee Graham Potter. This scarcity of English coaches at the zenith of the country’s football pyramid is not a new phenomenon, with the Premier League never being won by a manager of its home origin since its establishment in 1992. The controversial appointment of German Thomas Tuchel as the national team’s manager, the third time a foreign coach has been designated the role since the turn of the century, is also a sign of a larger issue. As a nation, England is not producing enough high-quality coaches. Why is this the case, and why aren’t other nations experiencing the same? The answer seems to lie in the high costs of being a coach in England, and the exclusivity faced often limiting their prospects.
With the Premier League considered by most to be the pinnacle of the sport in terms of quality, the clubs who play within it reasonably want the best coaches managing their teams in order to be competitive, and most have the resources to do so. The nationality of a potential coach is a low priority, meaning there is little special treatment or prioritisation of English coaches outside of their respective club connections. The reputation of the league alongside the financial capabilities of the teams within it allow clubs to acquire the best coaches internationally, providing fierce competition for homegrown coaches.
Yet the pool of English managers is significantly smaller than other major football nations. In order to manage in the Premier League or any European country’s top division, coaches must possess a UEFA Pro Licence. According to the English Football Association, there are less than 500 individuals in England who have earned this qualification, significantly less than many of the country’s footballing rivals including Spain, Portugal and Germany and even nations most would consider to be uncompetitive with the likes of the aforementioned, such as Turkey and Czechia.
Obtaining a UEFA Pro Licence requires the completion of an 18-month course, costing ÂŁ13,700 to participate
One reason behind the lack of English coaches attaining UEFA Pro Licences is the cost involved for individuals attempting to collect their coaching badges, compulsory qualifications needed to take charge of clubs at all levels of the footballing pyramid. Obtaining a UEFA Pro Licence requires the completion of an 18-month course, costing ÂŁ13,700 to participate. However, before that point, managers must accumulate all the necessary prerequisite coaching badges, mandatory before being allowed a chance of getting a Pro Licence, accumulating an overall price of ÂŁ19,710. These prices are much higher than those of other countries running the same or equivalent courses, with a UEFA Pro Licence in Spain or Germany reportedly costing up to and over ÂŁ10,000 less than in England, making them far more accessible to a wider field of aspiring coaches.
Even those who can afford to work towards the collection of their badges are not guaranteed a chance at getting on a course to get a Pro Licence. The spaces available to get on said courses are extremely limited, with the latest available information from the English Football Association indicating they offer only 24 places annually to those wishing to earn the qualification. In recent times, these exclusive slots have frequently been given to former big-name players such as Frank Lampard, Steven Gerrard and Wayne Rooney, whose reputation and name value may have taken precedence over their coaching ability when allocating the sparse positions. These same players have gone on to have limited success, all facing sackings at big clubs after being fast tracked into them. Comparatively, coaches abroad typically spend more time working their way up the sport’s competitive ranks, developing their craft and management as they go, leading to a larger selection of experienced and capable managers.
Whilst England has little issue in producing homegrown talent to play within its top division, the issues it has replicating this success in its coaching department is clear to see. The cost and inaccessibility involved in climbing the managerial ranks of English football borders on elitism. If the Premier League is to increase the number of English managers, major systematic change coaching development is in order, or else it will continue to be left behind by other nations’ standards of coaching. Decreasing the cost of coaching badges and increasing the number of placements available to qualify for a Pro Licence seems a sensible place to start.
Image: Ardfern via Wikimedia Commons

