Elections: Should we have a comprehensive policy?
Following the presidential election incident at Trevelyan College, News Features explores the different ways in which elections are conducted across the University.
Social Media
The disqualification of candidate Jeremiah Riad occurred because social media was used during his campaign.
While Trevelyan College bans the use of social media in an election campaign, a motion has since been proposed for it to be allowed.
This may increase voter participation and reach students who do not live in College, however concerns have been raised that it would prevent the college from being able to monitor the election process and stop any negative or unfair campaigning.
Ben Lambert the Trevelyan college JCR chair commented on the current rules: “The rules on social networking were considered and maintained as they are at last year’s constitutional review.”
The Durham Student Union elections, nominations for which opened on the 1st of February and include the position of Student President, do however allow candidates to use social media to aid their campaign.
While emailing to University mailing lists is not allowed, candidates are allowed to campaign on Facebook groups as long as these groups are public and can be monitored by the Union.
The DSU Elections are required to reach a far larger body of students than individual college or society elections and therefore require campaign methods which are further reaching.
Many students agreed that the difference between some Colleges and the Union elections was fair.
Cate Lough, a 3rd year Hatfield student said: “Elections in college don’t need social media as it’s quite a small place and canvassing is pretty easy, but it would be really hard to do this for the whole of Durham .”
Some colleges allow the use of social media during election campaigns.
At Hild Bede College, students are also allowed to use social media however they are not allowed to blanket email their online friends and have to individually name emails if they are using social media.
This is to prevent the competition from being judged on how many Facebook friends or Twitter followers a candidate has.
Lottie Birks, a 1st year Hild Bede student agrees with this policy and said: “Many people check their Facebook more than their University Email so using social media might encourage more voters.”
However she also saw the importance of candidates being active and recognizable during their campaign: “It is important that candidates make an appearance at dinner or in the JCR as otherwise it will just become a popularity contest.”
For most elections candidates are given a document with guidelines indicating the limitations on their activities. However some of these limitations can be unclear, particularly in regards to social media.
While a candidate may post a link to the voting site on their Facebook wall, this link can make no mention of the fact that they are standing.
In the case of Candidate Riad, although he had not started the Facebook page which encouraged voters, his activity on it indicated his awareness of its existence.
This awareness therefore justified the punishment.
Kirsty Walters, a Languages student at Trevelyan College said: “While it makes sense to ban social media to prevent the elections from just being a popularity contest, they need to be clearer about the guidelines for this.”
While Colleges want to keep elections as fair as possible, they also need to ensure that voter participation is high so that candidates chosen are as representative of the student body as possible.
Allowing the full use of social media may clear up any uncertainties concerning election campaigns.
Resource Restrictions
Candidates for DSU Elections may also only spend a maximum of £60 on their campaign.
Colleges also restrict the resources candidates can put into a campaign.
For a position in Van Mildert College, candidates are only allowed to distribute 100 A4 manifestos and 126 A5 manifestos, limiting the amount that can be spent on canvassing voters.
In previous years students running for positions within the DSU have been able to spend unlimited funds on their campaign which has been thought to disadvantage poorer candidates.
These resource restrictions ensure that money does not play a part in the voting process.
Most students spoken to agree that this restriction was good as it prevented any economic disparity from affecting the outcome of an election.
Simon Harris says that these restrictions should be viewed as a positive aspect of the elections:
“£60 is a small amount of money for a campaign, forcing candidates to plan effectively and be efficient. This demonstrates candidates’ additional abilities, such as efficiency, which are desirable in a successful candidate.”
Disciplinary Actions
Earlier this year a student at Van Mildert College standing for Senior Freshers Rep was banned from college for the remaining duration of the election, preventing him from canvassing students.
His conduct during the election was deemed to have breached regulations.
Actions taken by Colleges and the Union vary concerning candidates who have not followed the proper guidelines.
While at Trevelyan College the candidate in question was removed from the running, if the Student Union finds a candidate has committed a misdemeanor, the candidate is required to take remedial action within a given time scale.
Students applying for Student Union positions are required to attend a ‘Clean Campaign’ seminar to prevent any accidental breeches of the campaign guidelines.
No Canvassing
For many societies, positions are elected at an Annual General Meeting, where students give speeches and are the immediately voted for.
In some cases candidates are not allowed any election publicity or campaigning besides a manifesto which is emailed out before the election.
These strict regulations are put in place to make the campaigns and election results as fair as possible and to ensure that the best candidate is elected for the position, regardless of their popularity.
However some feel that while these restrictions are often put in place to stop the elections from merely being a popularity contest, they can actually make it into more of one.
Bea Cooper disagreed with this way of positions being allocated: “Just having a manifesto and no canvassing encourages popularity contests. People will just vote for names they know if they never get to meet the candidates.”
The differing approaches of societies, colleges and the union have their benefits and faults. However a comprehensive policy for all across the university may prevent any future uncertainties.
Photograph: Joanna Thom

