Election one week on: what does the future hold for the United Kingdom?
By Miriam Brittenden

Pollsters had predicted maybe 50 SNP seats by Friday morning, but actually watching the SNP manage 56, wiping out Scottish Labour, but for a single seat, was flabbergasting stuff. Casualties of a number of prominent Labour faces, Shadow Foreign Secretary Douglas Alexander and Scottish Labour leader Jim Murphy, really brought the reality home.
But what does this result mean for the Union? Though there was plenty of scaremongering in the weeks prior to the 7th May about the fated Labour-SNP combo, the result we have ended up with, an SNP Scotland and a Tory Britain, (thanks mostly to the votes cast in England) is arguably far more scary in terms of implications for the UK. Cameron may still be toasting his victory, but not far from the back of his mind will be the fact that his government arguably has almost no legitimacy north of the border. At least the SNP had been willing to work with Labour, but this is certainly not the case with the Tories, cast lovingly as the ‘bogey men’ of British politics by the SNP and the Yes Campaign of 2014. Like a divorced couple living under the same roof, this election has polarised England and Scotland now more than ever.
Why though, if the Scots said no to Independence in September 2014 (albeit by a slim majority) have so many voted for the SNP this time? Many have argued that Scottish voters, having lost faith in a Labour which had become too much ‘like the rest’ of the Westminster establishment in the past 20 years, despite Miliband’s attempt to pull it back to the left, look to the SNP as a better, more scrupulously and honestly left wing alternative party of the ordinary Scot. Nicola Sturgeon’s anti-austerity pledges are attractive to many in a post-depression era. Others would say it’s just another fist being shaken at the political establishment, of a people disaffected by current politics, in the same way people in England or Wales might vote Green or UKIP. But what cannot be forgotten is that fundamentally, at its core, the Scottish Nationalist Party is just that, a nationalist party, and whatever else Sturgeon might say, the party stands for independence. That so many people in Scotland voted for such a party is something which cannot be ignored.
With 56 MPs in the commons, and the third largest party in the Commons, Westminster politics will certainly look a little different from now on. But with an austerity-ready Tory majority government, how much influence will the nationalists and their anti-austerity really have? Cameron, wary of making the scab of Scottish nationalism any worse than it already is, and painfully aware of the legitimacy he is lacking in Scotland, will be treading carefully. But equally, this is a Tory majority government we’re talking about, no longer held back by the nice and moderate Liberals. What if the SNP can’t deliver expectant Scottish voters the influence they so passionately voted for, what then? Could we see not disillusionment this time but anger, loud calls for another referendum, but this time it’s not just a maybe, this time the Union will break up for good.
What will be left? A hollowed out, barely-United Kingdom, unsure of its identity or purpose. In their manifesto, the Conservative Party promised to devolve further powers to Scottish Parliament and the Welsh Assembly, as well as introducing ‘English votes for English Laws’. But this may not be enough to save a broken marriage. A ‘people-led’ constitutional agreement to determine the future of the UK’s governance, as other parties had suggested in their manifestos, would be a greater step towards addressing this problem. Because it is English identity, in particular, as well as Scottish identity, which is at stake here.
The election result may have been far more predictable than polls had predicted, but it cannot just be business as usual. All is not well in Britannia, the constitution is in a state of crisis. This is an issue that Cameron and indeed the UK needs to face up too, and fast. It cannot be just the elephant in the room. Majority government or not, the Scottish result certainly didn’t disappoint on the ‘messy’ factor.
Photograph: flickr via Creative Commons
