Egypt’s next move must be to fix its Economy

9180915080_3706be4595_n

by Richard Morgan

Since the overthrow of Mohamed Morsi on the 30th June, ‘the Egyptian economy has slowed almost to a halt,’ reports the BBC’s Tim Wardle. The political instability has exposed the economic issues the country has been battling for decades. 

Galal Amin, Professor of Economics at the American University in Cairo, stated ‘without fear of making a mistake’ that this was the worst economic crisis Egypt faced since the Great Depression.

The crisis begins with actual revenues for Egyptians remaining stagnant, or in some cases falling.

A perceived lack of safety has meant the crucial tourism industry for Egypt has been hit the hardest. Holly Williams of CNN reported that, “The pyramids stand deserted, foreign tourists being frightened off” by the political uncertainty. 

Another local businessman from Tunis explained, “Our pots are just sitting on the shelves, we used to deliver to shops, exhibitions and export overseas.” Other industries continue to shrink from a lack of investment resulting in an overall unemployment rate of 20%. Amongst young Egyptians, unemployment is at 25%.

Whilst income plunges, prices soar to “unsustainably high levels,” which Angus Blair, President of Signet Institute, explains are due to the devalued Egyptian pound, which has lost 12 points on the US dollar.

Both former Presidents Hosni Mubarak and Mohamed Morsi did not attempt to strengthen the currency, choosing to dip into foreign currency reserves to pay for import goods. This move depleted Egypt’s foreign reserves from £24 billion in 2010 to £9.5 billion reported in June 2013.

Ali Essa, chairman of Misr, an Egyptian farming company, said he struggles to afford the prices of imported fertilizers and machinery, meaning Egyptian businesses lack the capital to produce goods the people need.

Egyptian businesses also suffer from rising fuel costs as a result of the weak currency and weak economic regulation. Currently, sellers of fuel are ignoring regulation to sell at a reasonable price. Mr. Alzarak, a local farmer, stated that some Egyptians are buying imported fuel from State-owned Egyptian General Petroleum Corp, then taking advantage of the shortage of fuel and selling it on the black market for three times the price of the subsidized amount. 

Higher prices have meant consumers now devote more of their disposable income on necessities. Statistics reveal 25% of households now spend 50% of their income on food alone. Meanwhile, the government, depleted of cash, cannot subsidize essential good markets.

Mr. Radwan, a development economist, states that 25.2% of Egyptians live below the poverty line and 23.7% hover just above it, but could easily fall below it if inflation is prolonged.

The political unrest and absence of law have also frightened away big domestic investors. Mr. Sawiris, a native Egyptian Billionaire, said: “For two and a half years I personally have not invested a penny here.” Foreign Investors are also detracted by the risk of investing in Egypt. Ms. Glover, CEO of Amadeus Capital Partners Ltd, a London-based venture capital business that invests across the world, has stated that she would only give foreign investment to Egyptian businesses that can export, so if the Egyptian market is unsuccessful they would at least have other countries’ business to reduce the loss.

If instability continues, the next problem Egypt will face is a brain drain of skilled professionals.

Experts have already seen a trend this summer of departing middle class families. Mrs. Nabila, a housewife in a middle class family, explained why she is considering leaving for Europe: “Though I love my country, I love my kids more.” She does not want her children growing up in a country with a weak police force and economic instability.

Solving these economic problems was delayed by Mr. Morsi’s failed economic policies. In 2011, Egypt’s former leaders refused a $3billion loan and a sound financial and monetary program from the International Monetary Fund (IMF). Mr. Radwan, the current economic governor for Egypt, said Mr. Morsi “didn’t want to leave a legacy of debt” and wanted to focus his energy on gaining new legislative power for himself. Mr. Radwan holds that this created political instability and caused investors and the IMF to lose trust in Egypt.

The country has now finally been granted a $4.8billion loan from the IMF and a $12billion contingent loan from the EU. Mohamed Osama al-Khely, an Egyptian banker, believes this will improve the country’s chances of getting foreign investment, but that more must be done to make Egypt attractive to overseas business.

For the time being, foreign investment continues to be scared away from Egypt due to political uncertainty and the vicious cycle of rising inflation stunting Egyptians from starting up businesses.

Egyptian citizens want to restore stability, tourism and confidence from investors in their country. In response to this public sentiment, the temporary military-based administration has appointed experienced policy makers, whose “very existence may go some way to restoring business confidence,” said Mohamed Kotub of Naeem Financial Investment in Cairo.

Yet, in a competitive global economy, Egypt will have to do more to attract the investment that will jump-start its economy.

Photograph: Mahmoud Gamal El-Din