Editorial #878: Why Durham’s student democracy needs fixing
By Will Dixon
This year has been a big one for the ballot. Around the world 76 countries have held or will hold elections – Palatinate goes to press on the eve of the biggest one, the election of the President of the United States (we cover both candidates in our Politics section on page 16-17).
Back in Durham, we are represented by more elected officers than all the elected officials in the US federal government combined. Albeit their responsibilities and campaign expenditure are slightly less than those running for a seat in Washington – Durham Students’ Union sets a hard limit of £80 for campaigns.
Every year, various outlets try and codify different countries’ governments into an overall democracy score. It is measured through getting a group of experts to rate different questions on democracy a yes or a no. For instance, they ask them: to what extent representatives influence policy, how contested elections are, and how many people bother to vote. Last year, the Economist Intelligence Unit gave Britain 8.28 marks out of 10, making it a full democracy.
There are two big problems with student democracy in Durham: students’ engagement with these representatives and the co-ordination of the representatives themselves around issues. This is because representation is split between faculties, JCRs, the Students’ Union and some powerful student societies.
The engagement problem is the trickier fix, Durham likely compares well compared to other universities in this regard. Most students are members of their JCRs, where most of Durham’s democracy goes on. Engagement with them depends on how large and cliquey their JCR is. The best encourage participation by making their meetings inviting: keeping them short, having good outreach and communication, and making sure discussions stick on point and do not descend into exec in-jokes.
Back in Durham, we are represented by more elected officers than all the elected officials in the US federal government combined
Most colleges have a student who is elected to focus full-time on representing students’ interests. This fosters a close relationship between President and College officers which works to the benefit of students by making changes from within individual colleges.
This does not scale up to good representation at the University level. Collectively, in Presidents’ Committee, JCR presidents often appear poorly coordinated on issues affecting students generally. This makes sense given those they are accountable to – their college JCRs, not students in general.
This means they rarely make substantive joint statements, if they did, they would be powerful. For instance, earlier this term, Presidents’ Committee published a rousing open letter detailing how student volunteers at catered colleges were receiving fewer free meals this year than they had enjoyed previously. The lead authors managed only to convince just over half of college presidents to add their signatures to the letter. This is for good reason. Self-catered colleges volunteers were given free meals for the first time, making their presidents less reluctant to criticise the policy.
Therefore, Presidents’ Committee clearly needs to become more powerful. They should give more power to their chair to represent the committee to staff and ensure that future join statements are either unanimous or near unanimous. It should meet more regularly and have access to the Students’ Union’s staff to assist with administrative work and for communicating through channels of communication and advice for engaging with the University.
Increasing co-ordination between JCR Presidents does not need to eclipse what the SU does, it should complement it. Student representatives should be pragmatic and above petty factionalism. They should represent pastoral, equality, diversity and inclusion and student experience issues. The SU and faculty representatives should work together on educational issues. It is too often that the three main forms of student representatives do not work together.
Our fellow students need representatives who can have access and work well with the University. The structure of democracy; therefore, needs further reform.
Image: Ashley Zhou

