East meets West at the V&A

By Stephanie Lamchina-2

On the 26th November the Victoria and Albert Museum launched their new temporary exhibition, ‘Masterpieces of Chinese Painting 700-1900’, which will be on show until 19th January.

My view of this exhibition is inevitably influenced by my upbringing in Hong Kong – a city that is first and foremost one of China, but which retains Western influences from its British colonial history. And as I walked through the exhibition, I could not help but notice the disparity between Chinese culture as I knew it, and the way it is presented in the V&A.

The exhibition is arranged chronologically with large notices explaining the period of art, and it was in these notices that I found the most obvious traces of ‘Westernization’. The periods are split by numerical dates; the first few are titled ‘Objects of devotion 700-950’, ‘The Quest for reality 950-1250’, ‘Embracing solitude 1250-1400’. As conventional and logical as this way of splitting time periods is to a Western audience, it is not the normal practice in China when referring to a time in history.

Imperial China was split into dynasties and the names of the dynasties – Zhou, Yuan, Han and so on – are familiar to most of the literate Chinese population. These dynasty names are used as reference for time divisions, in preference over numerical time divisions such as nineteenth century and eighteenth century.

The shift in the way in which time is divided is more than a superficial difference; it indicates the underlying fundamentally different cultural beliefs and practices between the West, as represented by the V&A, and China. The numerical timescale diminishes one of the basic ways in which Chinese people understand their own history. One of the subtle, but important, underlying assumptions that accompanies the practice of identifying time by dynasties, is that each dynasty possesses its own character.

The descriptions used in the first half of the exhibition suspiciously echo lexical choices used to describe European art movements. The art of the Song dynasty is described as a ‘quest for reality’ and ‘an age of reason’ – phrases that are uncomfortably similar to vocabulary used in reference to Van Eyck’s Arnolfini Wedding and the Enlightenment. Whether this is a conscious reflection on the curious parallels between the development of art across the world, or the unintentional warping of Chinese art history to fit with Western understanding, is probably a question worth pondering.

Placed in the context of the artworks on display however, the exhibition’s estrangement from Chinese culture in its descriptions is perhaps forgivable, given the incredible choice and range of artworks on display.  

The early exhibits of the eighth to tenth centuries are breathtaking records of the long and well-preserved history of Buddhism in China. To me, the bodhisattva images are eerily similar to the paintings, stone statues and carvings in the laymen temples around Hong Kong which date no earlier than the eighteenth century.

the exhibition’s estrangement from Chinese culture is forgivable, given the incredible choice and range of artworks on display

The rest of the exhibition is a dizzying demonstration of the technical and thematic development of Chinese art through the centuries. The ambitious time period covered by the exhibition means that often a technique or a movement only has one or two supporting paintings, but these are exquisitely well-chosen.

Some paintings enlighten viewers of the sophistication behind brushwork painting, for example Mi YouRen’s Cloudy Mountains (1140s, Song Dynasty). This scroll is placed in a glass case which allows the viewer to examine it closely. Mi You Ren’s use of his ‘Mi-dots’ to render impressionistic landscapes in this painting is strikingly memorable.

Then there is Chen Rong’s Nine Dragons (1244, Song Dynasty), in the form of a handscroll. Who would ever think that a gray scale depiction of dragons and clouds could be so alive, so fascinating?

A bewildering range of themes is on display – early Buddhist offerings, political statements, lyrical pieces, court-commissioned paintings. Gong Kai’s Emaciated Horse (1250s, Yuan Dynasty) represents a powerful political statement of the suffering of the under Mongol rule. Right beside this, Qian Xuan’s Doves and Pear Blossoms After Rain (c. 1235 Yuan Dynasty) is achingly lyrical – its symmetry and subdued palette evoke Qian’s sorrow at the Mongol regime.

The panoramic masterpieces which come up towards the end of the exhibition include The Four Wangs: Wang Shimin, Wang Jian, Wang Hui, Wang Yuanqi. Wang Jian’s Landscapes in the Manner of Old Masters (1669-1773, Qing Dynasty), a set of twelve hanging scrolls, magnificently spans a whole wall with mesmerizing mountains and waters. Another set of twelve scrolls, Yuan Jiang’s vision of The Palace of Nine Perfections (1691, Qing Dynasty), boldly celebrates the life of the luxurious.

One of the absolute highlights of the panoramic paintings is Xu Yang’s Prosperous Suzhou (1759, Qing). A scroll spanning 1.2 metres was blocked by a long line of viewers as I approached. Vaguely irritated at first, I soon joined the ranks of the ogling viewers. Throughout the scroll, the painting is painstakingly detailed – shops can be distinguished by their plaques, the city is teeming with people engaged in a mind blowing range of activities, and I could even see the blue and white china patterning on the bowl of a customer at a noodle shop.

This exhibition holds too much that is too well displayed for anybody to walk out disappointed. It is a tantalizing glimpse into the world of Chinese art, but it is even more accurately described by Richard Barnhart as “a visual record of cultural identity without parallel in the world.” Not only is it worthy of one visit, but it would stand up to multiple visits.

Photograph: ‘Prosperous Suzhou’ (1759) by Xu Yang, courtesy of The Independent