Durham’s ‘silent’ comedy boom makes noise at the Fringe

By Kate Wilkinson
As August draws to a close, journalists everywhere scramble to sum up the jam-packed four weeks of the Edinburgh Fringe and select their lucky few ‘stand-out’ acts deemed truly excellent at this year’s festival. The handful of comics who make the headlining features are among over 2,000 acts that perform at the Fringe every year. Scouring the weekend papers, a couple of pleasingly familiar names caught my eye.
Give your back a pat Durham, the comedy you have spawned is doing really well at the moment. And not for no good reason: it’s pretty damn funny. Durham is entering a comedy golden age. You don’t know about it. But you’re about to.
All Durham graduates, Nish Kumar, Nick Mohammed (aka Mr Swallow), Ed Gamble, Tom Neenan, and sketch groups Massive Dad and WitTank were among the 2014 festival’s hottest tickets. Garnering strong praise, Kumar’s ‘bold and intriguing’ (The Guardian), 4-stars stand-up show ‘Ruminations on the Nature of Subjectivity’ has come top in many highlights reviews of this year’s Fringe. Nick Mohammed supplied audiences with what has been described as his ‘finest show to date’ (The Sunday Times) with his latest bombastic escapade in ‘Mr Swallow: The Musical’. Massive Dad was chosen by BBC’s Arts editor Will Gompertz to form part of his sketch comedy line up during an event at the Beeb’s festival hub. WitTank’s Naz Osmanoglu has had a good year; you can catch him alongside Tom Rosenthal in BBC 3’s Flat News.
But don’t just take the hype at face value. These acts have been in the making for some time, gaining in experience and reputation each year. I saw nearly all the aforementioned alumni at The Durham Revue’s eclectic ‘Allstars’ Gala event one languid June evening in 2013 and absolutely loved them. Kumar was performing as half of The Gentlemen of Leisure with Tom Neenan, Mohammed’s Mr Swallow character was a solo stand-up, Osmanoglu compered the evening, and Massive Dad’s Tessa Coates was back performing with The Durham Revue’s reunited 2010/11 group.

Fast forward a year and at Edinburgh last week I was the hipster who had seen the cool comedians before they were cool. I encountered Durham graduates pleasing crowds all over the comedy capital without even seeking them out.
It’s hard to explain exactly what makes Mohammed’s berserk Mr Swallow character so hilarious so I can only recommend you see him for yourself. Though his Gala performance was hardly your regular stand-up routine, in Mr Swallow’s brilliant new outing as musical theatre leading man (Count Dracula no less), Mohammed has given his lovable megalomaniac an ideal and highly original setting. Crafting a show to seem accidentally goofed up requires even more discipline than a straight musical. Mohammed’s show is both mad and polished. He had me and the friend I had persuaded (forced) to come with me in stitches.
Doing it for the girls Tessa Coates, Liz Smith, and Stevie Martin were brilliant as the sketch comedy trio Massive Dad. They excel at playing with refined manners in ridiculous situations. Their talk show debate between a sex writer and a ‘sex-denier’ about the existence of sex is a particular highlight.
Perhaps it’s hardly surprising that a decent university should have among its graduates some level of comedy talent. But when a massive slice of this talent does really well around the same time you might expect journalists to come running, trumpeting a comedy ‘golden age’ (essentially what I’m trying to do here). The most famous example of this phenomenon is of course with the Cambridge Footlights who had huge booms in British comedy during the 60s and 80s. Many from their show Beyond the Fringe (1960) went on to form Monty Python and the troupe who won the inaugural 1981 Perrier award included Emma Thompson, Stephen Fry, and Hugh Laurie.

Despite the many recent success stories, I don’t think many people automatically think of cutting-edge comedy when they think of Durham. Outgoing Durham Revue president Elgan Alderman told me that “Durham is definitely going through a comedy boom, and has been silently without anyone from Durham actually realising for several years now.” Though the group’s history might not be so well known, it is pretty extensive going back at least to actor Arthur Bostrom who led the group in 1973. Now Elgan argues that “The culture and history of comedy at Cambridge means that people join the Footlights almost expecting to make it big. Well now, the same could be said of Durham. Having seen former Revue members make successful careers out of comedy, just five years after they slept through lectures at Elvet Riverside just like I did, it definitely inspires us and makes us believe that we can be successful too.” Having graduated this summer, he is now looking to carve his own path as a stand-up.

Elgan’s claims are bold but well-supported. The success of many Durham comedy acts was certainly evident in August. Significant though this was, the Fringe is a bubble-world of sorts and success in Edinburgh doesn’t always translate nationwide. Just like the comedy greats of old, the likes of Nish, Nick, and Naz will have to break it on TV in order to gain wider renown. If Durham students aren’t even aware of their own comedic roots, how can we expect anyone else to recognise them?
Signs are looking good. Nick Mohammed has been working on various projects with the BBC for years now and only last week WitTank (who have featured on BBC 3 already this year) announced their E4 pilot for a new sit-com they are writing. In 2010, Mohammed told Palatinate that ‘You have to think of things as an investment for the future’. In 2014, hopefully that investment is about to pay off.
Photographs courtesy of edfringereview.com and The Durham Revue
The Durham Comedy Association (which can be found on Facebook) has been set up this year to encourage students to get involved, provide gig information and audition dates.
