Durham undecided as Oxbridge set to charge £9,000 fees

by Mei Leng Yew


Cambridge, Oxford and Imperial are all expected to raise tuition fees to £9000 a year for incoming students in 2012-13. It is expected that other high ranking institutions will follow suit, but Durham is yet to confirm where it stands.

This comes after Cambridge University’s working group on fees paper to the University Council reccommended that “the level of tuition fee charged from 2012 entry should be the maximum permissible.”

The authors of the internal report justify the proposal by arguing that “to charge less than £9000 might raise questions about our commitment to excellence since a reduced fee in the long term could only be sustained by reducing costs and hence quality.”

Oxford University’s Pro Vice-Chancellor (Planning & Resources), Tony Monaco, has also said that Oxford will charge students at least £8000 a year, following the 80 per cent cut to higher education teaching funds.

Deputy PM Nick Clegg has objected to the planned rises.

“They can say what they like. They can’t charge £9000 unless they are given permission to do so.

“They’re only going to be given permission to do so if they can prove they can dramatically increase the number of people from poorer and disadvantaged backgrounds who presently aren’t going to Oxford and Cambridge.”

A Durham University spokesperson said that a decision had not yet been taken regarding tuition fees.

Last week on 10 February, the coalition announced plans to improve social mobility. Business Secretary Vince Cable wrote to the Office for Fair Access instructing them to set individual quotas in order to increase “the number of students admitted from state schools or colleges”.

Sir Martin Harris, Director of the Office Fair Access, has also been asked to “focus more sharply” on particular institutions such as Oxford and Cambridge.

Universities who agree to take steps towards meeting such quotas will then be allowed to charge tuition fees above the basic rate of £6000.

Cable has suggested that universities meet their targets by offering students from disadvantaged backgrounds heavily subsidised accommodation, a free foundation year, fee waivers or bursaries.

Places could also be offered “on the basis of lower entry qualifications” than an equally-qualified candidate from a more advantaged background would receive. Greater emphasis could also be placed on “contextual data”, which recognises the achievements of pupils who have had to overcome significant obstacles.

The University’s advice on 2012 entry tuition fees can be viewed here.

The University’s progress would be reviewed annually and assessed against performance benchmarks, with those failing to meet access targets potentially facing fines of up to half a million pounds.

The coalition’s plans have been opposed by Conservative backbenchers who have signed a Commons motion in protest.

The Chairman of the Education Select Committee, Graham Stuart MP, said “penalising universities for refusing to drop their standards is shameful. To suggest that they have some sort of bias against children from poorer backgrounds is a profound insult.”

Stuart claims that the new blueprint fails to address the real reasons behind the low numbers of state-educated students attending higher tier universities. “We need to improve the quality of schooling, not dumb down the entry requirements for universities.”

The Universities Minister David Willetts insisted that he did not want to see universities forced to accept “crude quotas”.

He said: “It would be wrong to say we are going to put in the bin all applications from private schools.”

Dr Wendy Piatt, the director-general of the Russell Group also expressed her concerns over the coalition’s plans.

“Admission to university is and should be on the basis of merit. Any decisions about admissions must respect the autonomy of institutions and maintain high academic standards.”

However, Mr Clegg defended the new plans: ” using the leverage that we have got over universities in terms of not giving them permission to charge over £6000 unless they give greater access to their universities to people like you, I actually think will make the university system fairer.

“This is not about social engineering. It is about creating a generally fair playing field for all our young people.”

The University’s advice on 2012 entry fees can be viewed here.