Durham graduate in diversity row

Durham graduate David Maddison, previously of Grey College, is one of ten high court judges appointed under new diversity rules.

Despite attempts to introduce variety into judicial appointments, those appointed appear to be white, middle to upper class males, most of whom have been privately educated.

It has led some to question whether the newly established Judicial Appointments Commission is achieving its purpose. According to Keith Vaz, a barrister and the Labour MP who chairs the Commons Home Affairs Committee, the system is “actually worse,” than before.

The new Judicial Appointments Committee set up in 2006, was meant to end old ‘tap on the shoulder’ style recruitment. The Committee set itself three tasks: defining merit, determining effective and fair methods of assessing merit and how best to encourage a wider range of applicants.

Despite aiming to encourage more applicants from females and ethnic minorities, of the 108 current judges only ten are women and only one is from an ethnic minority. It appears the government is falling well short of its target.