Durham adopts new access policies
Durham University is to raise the number of places given to state school applicants as part of its access agreement with the Government’s Office of Fair Access (OFFA), causing fears of discrimination against students from fee-paying schools.
The agreement follows the controversial appointment of Professor Les Ebdon as future director of OFFA earlier this year. He threatened that universities which do not widen participation will face ‘the nuclear option’, sanctions which enable OFFA to fine universities £500,000 or prevent them from charging more than £6,000 tuition fees.
As well as increasing the percentage of state school and college entrants to 62% by the 2015/16 academic year, the University is also aiming to increase the number of entrants from lower socio-economic backgrounds to 15%, a figure which would be only 3% lower than the sector average.
Since 2002, numbers of entrants from independent schools has steadily risen from 32.1% to 36.63%, while privately-educated students in Classics and Ancient History make up nearly 80% of entrants this academic year.
The University allocates students via the National Statistics Socio-economic Classification (NS-SEC), but this information cannot be provided by UCAS in advance, causing problems with enforcing its fair access policy. The new agreement shows that the University has decided to implement a new geodemographic profiling dataset, ACORN, “to assist in the identification of disadvantage”.
Several other higher education institutions including Cambridge, Exeter and Warwick have joined Durham in promising to take more state-educated students, with UCL planning a 10% rise in state admissions. However, independent school leaders hit back at the agreements, calling them “generic discrimination”.
Tim Hands, master of Magdalen College School, Oxford, said, “Universities don’t see why tertiary education should be forced to compensate for problems which government incompetence over secondary education has created in the first place”. There is a worry that disadvantaged students receiving bursaries and scholarships at independent schools may face discrimination, while some well-off state students may be at an unfair advantage.
The director general of the Russell Group, Wendy Piatt, spoke against the imposition of targets, suggesting instead that state schools’ grades be improved and application numbers increased. “By encouraging more qualified students from state schools to apply to us through outreach and access schemes, our universities will have a wider pool of applicants from which to select the brightest and the best”.
As part of its aim to increase applications by students from lower socio-economic backgrounds, Durham already has such a project in place, called the Supported Progression Scheme. It helps to remove financial, academic and admissions barriers for disadvantaged local students. The University acknowledges that although “there are significant disparities in prior attainment across school type… academic achievement remains the most important factor in determining which applicants receive an offer of a place”.

