DULOG has a hard time

Otto Rich thought Assassins did its job, but wasn’t quite special enough

FOLLOWING THE SUCCESS of this year’s DULOG Gala show, and with a short rehearsal time of just a month, director Steph Smith was always going to have a hard time to continue the society’s run of high-quality, enjoyable musical theatre.

And in the choice of Stephen Sondheim’s Assassins, Smith, together with musical director Pops Barham, choreographer Alexia Papaspyrou and producer Nick Boalch had definitely not taken on an easy show.

Assassins tells the story of the various attempts, both successful and failed, on the lives of American presidents; from Abraham Lincoln to JFK. But rather than focusing on the presidents or the events themselves, Sondheim focuses on the killers: their stories, backgrounds and mind-sets that caused them to attempt the ultimate murder. However, the show was all the more challenging
as, unlike most other scripts chosen by DULOGY, Sondheim’s piece is both musically and theatrically intricate; I would therefore argue that Smith had a far harder job than most directors of musical theatre in Durham. Not only is the show all-singing and all-dancing, but the plot-line is complicated and the characters deep, meaning that the cast have to be extremely good all-rounders for Assassins to succeed.

I commend Smith for her vision and ambition in putting on this production; one of the more challenging to happen in Durham this year. This vision was at once evident in her striking choice of set, and although I would argue that the Assembly Rooms is not a good venue in which to stage a complicated musical with a cast of fifteen, Smith and stage manager Laura Tickell produced a stunning backdrop of a 1920s speakeasy. Lighting and technical effects were fantastic too – commendations to Ella Parry-Davies and Ian Wenkenbach for this – particularly at the moments of the assassinations.

Sadly, on the stage itself, the performance was at times less than sharp. Things didn’t get off to a good start with the music all but drowning out the speakeasy’s proprietor, Mike Bunch, and John Wilkes-Booth, played by Simon Radford, leaving me with absolutely no idea what was going on in the opening scene of the show. Radford’s dubious southern drawl was also difficult to understand and his acting began shakily, though he returned towards the end of the play far stronger and more relaxed into his character and I actually grew to think of his performance as one of the better ones.

Good performances also came from Aleks Kizimovich, whose dry, witty portrayal of assassin Sarah Jane Moore had me chuckling on numerous occasions, and I felt that she not only really engaged with the character but also brought a lot of her own touch to the role. Mike Shaw also stood out, and his talent in holding the audience’s attention shone through in his long soliloquy telling the story of Sam Byck. But many other parts were weak; awkward, incomprehensible accents and a lack of engagement with characters were frequent.

Musically the Balladeer Will Davies and John Hinckley (Tom Garnett) were a highlight: exceptionally strong singers who more than rose to the challenge of the loud band and complex score. But again overall performances on the musical front were mixed and generally suffered from a lack of diction. The words were all but inaudible and were often drowned out by the band, despite most of the cast being miked.

Things picked up, particularly towards the end, and the choreography and dancing was hard to fault; particularly impressive were the Bystanders (Jess Taylor, Sam Morgan, Rob Richmond, Nikki Jones and Jon Gracey), whose ‘freezes’ in the middle of dance numbers worked well. The last few numbers were far more polished and the show finished on a high. The audience gave rapturous applause, and essentially I feel the production provided an entertaining diversion from a dull, dissertation-filled part of the year.

In conclusion I commend Steph Smith and the show’s production team for a seriously good effort considering the challenge Assassins presents; it’s no Guys and Dolls. But there were serious problems with some characters, and I also don’t understand the decision to deny the audience an interval in a production that was a good two hours long. Assassins did its job, but with more rehearsal time and polish, the cast could have gone further towards making Sondheim’s work something special.

In future DULOG should perhaps think harder about putting on such a demanding show so soon after their main Gala event.