DUCFS 2022: champion of diversity or breeding ground for classism?
By Josie Lockwood
At the beginning of December, Durfess’s posts about Billy B hooligans and advent calendar etiquette were interrupted by some rather large claims about classism within the Durham University Charity Fashion Show (DUCFS).
Students accused the DUCFS model casting of being intrinsically classist, as an exceptionally large number of successful auditionees belong to Bailey colleges. Of the 52 models in this year’s fashion show, 31 are part of a Bailey college opposed to a ‘hill’ college, and over 40% of the total models are from Hatfield or Castle colleges. While this is a significant sum, is labelling this casting as classist a valid criticism?
I would argue that it is not. Although Durham University may be seen by some as an institution with a history of classism that undeniably continues today, DUCFS have been vocal in that they strive to embrace diversity. All students are encouraged to model for the fashion show. When auditions were promoted this year, the DUCFS Facebook page stated that the team aspires to work with “a wide range of models” that are “both physically diverse and diverse in thought”.
It is clear that the society’s team comprises individuals from diverse backgrounds
On the DUCFS Instagram page, this same dedication towards recruiting individuals of diverse backgrounds is highlighted. The auditions post emphasises that “there is no template for a DUCFS model” and that “everyone’s welcome”. It is therefore a fundamental part of the society’s vision to be inclusive. If you look at this year’s executive committee, it is clear that the team comprises individuals from diverse backgrounds who are keen to promote this same sense of diversity in the models chosen.
Indeed, when DUCFS published a ‘meet the models’ video, it was immediately clear that the models selected were diverse and there did not seem to be any discrimination between size, shape or colour. Why then, is there so much controversy emerging on the topic?
While at a first glance it is shocking that such a huge proportion of the models belong to Hatfield and Castle, it is important to scrape beneath the surface of this statistic. The models for DUCFS are chosen through volunteer sampling. It just so happens that this year, the majority of those who auditioned were part of Bailey colleges. Assuming that DUCFS is honest to its commitment in choosing models that align with their values of diversity and authenticity, college labels should not be a factor in their judgment.
At the end of the day, the models this year have already been selected and DUCFS is well under way. Rather than criticise their current choices, perhaps a more constructive approach would be looking forwards towards the future of the fashion show. Perhaps in coming years, a degree of anonymity should be favoured in the audition process, and models should not be required to share which college they belong to.
The very essence of a project where people are accepted or rejected due to their appearance will always provoke controversy
If DUCFS were to introduce quotas of students that ‘must’ be part of the model intake for that year, debate and dissension would still be provoked. If a rule was introduced that there ‘had’ to be at least one student from every college, or at least one plus size model, or an individual from a state school, surely this would prompt even more dispute. These students should not be discriminated against in the first place, and the notion of ‘having’ to cast them implies that they should be.
Instead, I believe that DUCFS should strive to continue being increasingly inclusive in any way that they can. There are already a number of steps they have taken to advocate inclusivity, such as making the starting ticket price of their February fashion show lower than ever before at just £38. In the same way that diversity is being encouraged in the show’s audience, perhaps introducing further measures such as anonymising college allocation could help bolster DUCFS’ commitment to their mission.
No system to organise the fashion show will ever be perfect. The very essence of a project where people are accepted or rejected due to their appearance will always provoke controversy. It is therefore important that DUCFS continue to combat the ‘Durham stereotype’ and champion inclusivity in coming years, as they are currently endeavouring to do so.
Image: DUCFS via Facebook

