Does anyone still care about the evils of capitalism?
Nothing is more typical of the age in which we live than the bland, inoffensive labels that Facebook prescribes for our ‘political views’. Are you a liberal, a conservative or a libertarian? Can you even tell the difference?
As the USSR crumbled, Labour strategists concocted ‘New Labour’ – the end of socialism in mainstream British politics. Radical solutions to big problems were not only abandoned on a practical level, they became unthinkable: totalitarian, obscene, or, as Facebook would have us say, ‘Other’.
The real obscenity, however, is the regular, robotic, pompous claim that the young need to be more engaged with politics. What are we expected to engage with? There is no politics, there is only the dramatic spectacle of the Westminster rabble and the dull selection of more or less competent administrators with very similar managerial values. Parliament is captured exactly in the phrase ‘office politics’: the Home Office, Ricky Gervais’s office, your office. There is no longer any voice for unofficial political thought.
Yet here is a political thought that I can guarantee you will not like. The problem of human trafficking, aptly stated by Rachael Revesz (page 10), is the awkward spillage of global poverty onto our own streets: it is the embodiment of an evil that we all support.
What is slavery? Is there a philosophical difference between ‘forced’ labour and paid labour? The freedom of the worker is the same as the freedom you have not to jump if I put a gun to your temple and shout: ‘Jump!’
Ethical campaigning, like Stop Traffic, is admirable in so far as it aims to give a human face to the violence that is written into the structure of capitalism, but nevertheless its emotive rhetoric and microscopic focus distract us from the true nature of the problems it demands that we solve.
Many of us have expressed cynicism about campaigns like Make Poverty History, but what is it exactly that makes us feel uneasy about them? Is it that the celebrities who mobilise us to ethical actions are egotistical? Is it that their extravagant lifestyles make them hypocrites? Is it that we don’t want to feel harassed about our own lifestyles?
It is all these things, but at the same time none of these reasons quite captures the point. What underlies the problem of all ethical campaigning is the unavoidable hypocrisy of challenging one injustice while enacting a hundred others by merely living and consuming. The lie is that a particular problem can be isolated from the structural traits of capitalism and solved by practical, official methods like lobbying governments. Geldof and Bono rub shoulders with Blair: the status quo is now a medium for collaboration, not an object of suspicion.
Meanwhile, the anarchist riots that annually accompany G8 summits are either sneered at as thoughtless adolescent violence or ignored entirely by the world’s press.
The same dynamic of hypocrisy and selective empathy can be seen at work in the way we think about Western humanitarian interventions.
Prof. Mahmood Mamdani of Columbia University spoke convincingly in Durham two weeks ago about the Save Darfur campaign. Save Darfur is the strongest student activism movement in America since the campaign against the South African apartheid. Yet the movement is premised on a death-count in Darfur that has been demonstrated false, and on a notion of ‘racial genocide’ which is at best a massive simplification of the situation. That is not to say that there is not terrible political violence in Darfur, but the call for Western intervention is far from obviously a worthy one, and the call for China to stop trading with Sudan is another act of hypocrisy: Chinese wages, after all, are still not in league with our own.
These criticisms of the movement have not stopped Steven Spielberg, Mia Farrow and Don Cheadle from raising the profile of the campaign at every opportunity. Even if there were a realistic or sensible intervention, the concern over Darfur seems utterly perverse when you consider that just south of Sudan the war in Congo is reckoned to have killed 5.4 million people in the last decade (more than ten times the overblown figure Save Darfur cites for the conflict in Sudan) with a current death-rate of about 45,000 per month.
Why hadn’t you heard of this? Because thinking about this war would unravel some difficult truths. There is no ‘racial genocide’ narrative to be told; commentators cannot therefore use the word ‘Holocaust’ to convince you of the seriousness of the situation, even though the death-count is comparable. Congo is ravaged by armies and militias whose primary objective is to gain control of precious metals to sell to Westerners. Coltan is a metallic ore that is required to make laptops, mobile phones and Playstations, and most of it comes from Congolese miners enslaved by militiamen.
In the words of Oona King (the excellent Labour MP ousted by George Galloway): “Kids in Congo were being sent down mines to die so kids in Europe and America could kill imaginary aliens in their living rooms.
This, too, is the irony of ‘Blood for Oil!’ – one of the slogans of the march against the Iraq war. We did not want the blood, but we certainly use the oil. Did we take Iraqi oil by force? No: we are buying it. We are richer than they are, so they go without oil. Is this, too, not a kind of violence?
Not, apparently, in the post-socialism age: the idea that we deserve what we own goes unquestioned. If we give any of it away then we are especially good people. Business is now a friend of ethics. Oil companies advertise their environmental credentials, Bill Gates campaigns for justice, Starbucks sells ‘fair trade’ coffee: the answer to the world’s problems, we are told, is corporate responsibility.
Ethical protest, in other words, has been absorbed into the market. Campaigns become brands: Save Darfur has raised millions of dollars from its supporters, which it mostly spends on advertising for its dubious cause.
Just as businesses have become more ‘ethical’, charities have becomes more slick and businesslike. Charities spend a large chunk of the money they raise on raising more money. For example by hiring those annoying people who accost you on Framwellgate bridge, as Anton Lazarus has rightly complained in Mostly Harmless recently.
Like a Catholic confessional, these schemes function in part as a form of absolution: once you have ‘done your bit’ you can get on with thinking about other things. Charity has replaced religion as the institution of ‘forgiveness’ in our society, and the psychology is just as worthy of suspicion as it always has been. You can now buy the warm fuzzy feeling of being a good person.
So how can we authentically respond to human suffering? I don’t want to discourage charity, but charity should always be carried out with a heavy heart and a perceptive eye for ideology. The notion of a worldwide pop concert for charity is nothing short of grotesque: save the world and have a big party at the same time!
The constant imperative of the modern moral market is that our ethical reactions must be immediate: How many children have died in the time it took you to read this article? All that is needed for evil to succeed is for good people to do nothing, etc. etc.
But the real ethical challenge is for us all to resist this urgency and instead spend a little more time trying to understand the dynamics of the world of which we are a part.
