Doctors warn halting of non-COVID healthcare will cause preventable deaths
By Elena Liciu
As the coronavirus outbreak swept the UK in March, the majority of NHS services were branded as non-essential, and immediately closed. Overnight, patients across the country were left with limited access to healthcare professionals, no routine clinical appointments, and were strongly encouraged to ‘Stay Home’ in order to keep safe.
It is feared that such poor healthcare provision will trigger an increase in preventable non-COVID-related deaths that the NHS cannot afford to handle.
Doctors have now raised concerns over such drastic closures of non-COVID services, with the chair of the council of the British Medical Association declaring to the Guardian that patients were ‘simply left stranded’ during the virus outbreak. It is feared that such poor healthcare provision and strong state deterrence against seeking medical help will trigger an increase in preventable non-COVID-related deaths such as heart disease or cancer, as well as mass backlogs of undiagnosed disease, that the NHS cannot afford to handle.
Evidence from the lockdown period reinforces these concerns as the UK experienced a 40% increase in heart attack deaths, and between 30,000 to 40,000 patients experienced delayed cancer treatment. In addition, in the last 3 months there has been a 70% increase in non-COVID related deaths at home whilst the number of non-COVID deaths have been declining in hospitals. This suggests that people are either too afraid to seek medical attention when needed, or that due to lack of diagnosis testing they are unaware of their critical condition until it is too late to save their lives.
The UK experienced a 40% increase in heart attack deaths, and between 30,000 to 40,000 patients experienced delayed cancer treatment.
The future in regard to the coronavirus outbreak remains uncertain. Despite the decrease in the death toll, is it plausible we will be faced with another wave of the virus, making it vital to assess the effectiveness of such strict lockdown measures being reintroduced in the future. At the moment, the only impact NHS service shutdown has revealed has been the increase in the number of non-COVID deaths. Whilst this increase is alarming, it is possible it is not the worse to come.
It is predicated that people suffering from diseases which heavily rely on early diagnosis, most critically cancer, will be the most greatly affected. Oncologists have estimated that around 60,000 cancer patients may die as a direct result of failure to obtain an early diagnosis, or have rapid access to treatment. At first glance the discontinuation of diagnosis tests such as mammograms, CT and MRI scans appeared harmless, yet within the period of only three months, the halting of these essential tests have managed to completely unwind the ridged NHS diagnosis testing system, which enabled 1,000 new cancer cases to be detected daily within the UK. Now, as little as only 16% of the normal cancer cases are being diagnosed in comparison to normal figures. This lag in cancer diagnosis means many people will have cancer and simply not know it, making it a possibility that their condition will be less responsive to treatment, or even too advanced for treatment to be an option.
The question remains on what the correct approach is in the future.
As routine checks are being reintroduced, the NHS will be faced with the challenge of catching up with all missed diagnosis testing, whilst simultaneously coping with the wave of newly diagnosed patients. Therefore, the question remains on what the correct approach is in the future. As the government proceeds at full force to try and eradicate COVID-19 through a series of social distancing methods, local lockdowns, and the track and trace system, it is crucial to consider that the target of complete eradication of the virus might not be the most beneficial. If non-COVID services continue to be periodically shutdown, thousands of people will face delayed diagnosis and treatment, putting patients through a great deal of suffering as well as allowing them to die from preventable diseases.
Image by Ian Livesey via Flickr
