Doctors scolded for telling patients to fight the flab

By Lucy Kingsland

NHS-T-AP (1)

Doctors are increasingly being told by NHS Administrators to be “non- blaming” and “respectful” of obese patients, guided by words published in draft guidance by the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence last week. But in a climate of increasing demands on the NHS, limited resources and general austerity should doctors really be being told what language to use in their treatment rooms?

Nobody can overlook the British art in diplomacy when it comes to dealing with sensitive issues. But I hesitate as to whether we have reached a stage in which our inclination towards “pussy footing around” grim situations is costing our country time, energy and our increasingly limited NHS resources.

Yes, approaching sensitive topics with a degree of diplomacy is an admirable trait, and something that we British should be proud of; after all, our social and linguistic politesse is recognised the world over.  But when it comes to matters of social welfare and overseeing that our country is able to provide an efficient health service, should we be disposing of these polite mannerisms, so entrenched in the British psyche, in the aim of improving the NHS and by extension, other state services.

Of course no obese individual wants to hear their doctor calling them “fat” or advising them to cut down on the old pork pies, but honesty has always proven to be the best policy in the treatment of disease. And obesity is undeniably a disease if we interpret ‘disease’ in its literal meaning.

After all, if patients suffering from liver problems are not treated in such a delicate manner, then why should an overweight person, suffering from a mostly self-inflicted health problem be afforded such a luxury?

I am not blind to the fact that some obese people have a genetic predisposition to being overweight and am well aware of the back lash that my argument will face from the millions of overweight people around the world claiming to be one amongst this incredibly slim category. But unfortunately the results are glaringly clear that this predisposition to obesity is unfortunately and inconveniently representative of only a fraction of the population.

By no stretch of the imagination am I promoting the idea that doctors adopt a cold, brash approach to their overweight patients, nor am I saying they should be insensitive to these patients’ feelings.

However, the number of admonishments that doctors are facing from hospital administration with regard to such issues is quite frankly astonishing.

There seems to be a missing link in the chain here. Shouldn’t the doctor, the professional, he who owns the medical degree be left to fly the plane, to inform the patient of their health implications and leave the administrative staff to clear the runway?

Photograph: Telegraph/AP