Do you hear the people sing?

By Jonathan Penny

Classical conductor Daniel Barenboim hit the news earlier this month as his orchestra came together to perform a concert of western music in Gaza. The orchestra, which was made up of musicians from across the globe, performed an all-Mozart programme for an audience of schoolchildren and invited NGO workers.

Barenboim has long been an outspoken critic of the Israeli government, and this concert is the latest of his attempts to encourage the two sides to agree over a common ground: music. His project, the West-Eastern Divan orchestra has also received a lot of press coverage and in 2001 he caused a furore by performing a banned Wagner encore at a concert in Israel. The conductor, of Israeli descent, denies that the group is a peace movement and calls it “a project against ignorance”. His efforts are highly laudable – but has music ever had any bearing on politics?

Music and politicians

Politicians have often tried to use their tastes in music to appeal to voters. Labour’s campaign for the 1997 election used the D:Ream hit ‘Things Can Only Get Better’ to represent their call for a new government, after 18 years of Tory rule. Ironically enough, before last year’s momentous election Cunnah was quoted as saying, “We need to give Cameron a chance.”

The idea of feigning admiration for a band which is in vogue seems fairly pathetic, but this has become one of the politician’s most often used tricks. This can backfire, as when then Sir Geoffrey Howe named Cliff Richard’s ‘Summer Holiday’ as one of his Desert Island Discs in 1986; an incredulous Parkinson told Howe that the young ones didn’t listen to that 1962 hit any more. I wonder how the Arctic Monkeys felt the day the papers reported Gordon Brown’s love for ‘I Bet You Look Good On the Dancefloor’.

Often politicians have an adverse effect on music; Wagner has famously been tarred with the ‘Nazi’ brush because of his anti-Semitic writings and Hitler’s promotion of him as the ultimate Aryan composer. It is true that Wagner’s self-penned texts are super-nationalistic, but despite his anti-Semitic essays (which he wrote as a young man) he was good friends with a number of eminent Jews. Interestingly, Hitler himself was not an aficionado of Wagner’s music and preferred the lighter operettas of Lehár.

The Third Reich’s propaganda minister Goebbels banned music by the Jewish composers Mendelssohn and Mahler, as well as imposing strict rules governing the jazz music which had come across from the USA; these included an intolerance of “negroid excesses in tempo” and a ban on lyrics which promoted sexual promiscuity or were “Jewishly gloomy”. Jazz was dubbed Negermusik and was deemed unacceptable under the Nazi ideology, because of its black and Jewish connections. More optimistically, a number of books have been written about the underground jazz counter-culture which threatened Goebbels’ autocratic rule. Jazz not only survived the Nazis’ persecution efforts; it came to represent political dissidence in wartime Germany.

Music and politics

Poetry and song lyrics have long been an avenue to channel political opinion. Billie Holiday used to close her New York shows with a poignant song called ‘Strange Fruit’, which depicted the lynching of two black men in Indiana in 1939.

Southern trees bear strange fruit,

Blood on the leaves and blood at the root,

Black body swinging in the southern breeze,

Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees.

In the 1960s many musicians felt compelled to write songs about the US Civil Rights Movement, which took Pete Seeger’s ‘We Shall Overcome’ as its unofficial anthem. Bob Dylan was also influenced by the movement, and his ‘The Times They Are a-Changin’’ has been called the archetypal protest song. The song ‘War’, which provided hits for Edwin Starr in the ‘60s and Bruce Springsteen in the ‘80s contains a powerful political message for peace; “War, what is it good for? Absolutely nothing!”

The anarchy of punk swept the country during the 1970s, with The Sex Pistols’ ‘God Save the Queen’ one of the most controversial songs to define the era. The record came under fire for criticising the monarchy so brazenly, but the band’s frontman Johnny Rotten denied that the music or the band was of any political persuasion and that they just wanted “to destroy everything.”

U2’s ‘Sunday Bloody Sunday’ (1983) is possibly one of the most famous songs of its type. It tells of the tragedy a decade earlier, where British soldiers shot 26 unarmed protestors in Londonderry. Bono has said that the song is not one of protest, but of unification; evident in the line, “Tonight we shall be as one.”

Music, like any of the expressive arts, can be used to express political ideas or sentiments. Over the centuries, politicians have harnessed the power of music and attempted to restrict its influence. Israel does not restrict performances of Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana – a work lauded by, and some suggest even written for, the Nazi party – but Wagner remains banned in the concert hall.

Despite Barenboim’s best efforts, it seems that his pioneering orchestra still has a way to go.