Dishonourable killings in Jordan
By Shouq Majali
The commercialisation of Jordan’s stance on human rights as being among ‘the best and most respected in the Middle East’ made me extremely proud to call myself Jordanian. At first glance, Jordan has demonstrated a clear effort to reform laws governing human rights, however, upon further evaluation the 2017 reforms prove to be a mere façade of an unchanged and ironically dishonourable system.
A tragic case recently sparked outrage involving the killing of a 30-year old Jordanian woman by her father. Following the murder, the father proceeded to have a cup of tea and a cigarette by the corpse while awaiting the deceased’s uncles who proceeded to celebrate his actions. After years of domestic abuse and several attempts to receive help from protective services, Ahlam suffered at the expense of her country’s ignorance towards the protection of women from their families.
Ahlam’s story is only the tip of the iceberg. Despite there being no official figures on honour killings in Jordan, according to SIGI (Sisterhood is Global Institute: a women’s rights charity) at least 42 women were murdered by their relatives in 2016. Jordan has, in fact, the highest rate of honour killings in the world. Having such a high magnitude of cases clearly makes this a prominent issue in the country; it is therefore puzzling that no specific penal code provisions exist for investigating abuse. Despite the adoption of the 2008 Family Protection Act, domestic violence cases can only be prosecuted under the general provisions of assault and battery.
For far too long, individuals have hidden behind the Islamic veil to justify human rights violations. While many justify such murders as based on Islamic traditions, an Islamic legal pronouncement by Abu Arqoub stipulated that Sharia law strictly prohibits the killing of female relatives as representative of family honour: “anyone who commits such crimes should be held accountable and should not get a reduced sentence if the victim was a relative.” Assessment of the origins of the provision show that it was derived from a historic Syrian penal code adopted directly from the French penal code. While France has evolved to abolish this article, Jordan and many other Middle-Eastern countries continue to suffer the effects of colonisation and maintain their primitive laws.
Violence against women is anything but a political priority in Jordan, and progress remains slow.
Most spine-chilling of all, is Jordan’s ‘solution’ to all this familial inflicted abuse through the Crime Prevention Act (121 of 1927) which reserves the right to indefinitely detain the women being abused. This provision further intensifies female suffering as it gives the governorate Director the right to hold the woman under ‘protective custody’ to prevent a crime being committed against her. Over 65% of female inmates in Jordan are imprisoned to protect them from their families. The concealment of these victims through imprisonment while their perpetrators walk freely exacerbates the need for change.
The patriarchal nature of this system is further reinforced upon assessment of the methods of releasing these women from ‘protective custody.’ In order to be granted release, a male family member is required to act as a guarantor and sign an ‘order of protection’ – often these guarantors are the same individuals that posed the original threat on the women’s life which led to their imprisonment. Alternatively, another method of freedom involves an arranged marriage orchestrated by the system and signed by the governor.
Sharia law strictly prohibits the killing of female relatives as representative of family honour.
The imprisonment is rationalised by a lack of alternatives such as safe shelters for abused women. In 2017, a landmark decision was set to revolutionise women’s rights in Jordan when two brothers received a sentence of 15-20 years for killing their sister in the name of the family honour. Judge Tarawneh exclaimed this decision would “send a strong message to the people that killing women in the name of family honour will no longer be tolerated by our court.”
The supposed step forward was not reflected in the 2017 human rights reforms, though lawmakers amended article 98 to disallow reduced sentences for those who commit crimes against women. However, this pretence at progress is followed by a loophole under article 340 which allows mitigated sentences for men who murder their spouses upon discovering they’ve committed adultery.
Violence against women is anything but a political priority in Jordan, and progress remains slow. In 2017, authorities announced the opening of a protective shelter for women at risk, which was built a year later. To this day, women are still ‘gradually’ and slowly being moved into this new shelter. There exists an obligation on the Jordanian government to curb this conservatism of society and dedicate suitable financial means to aiding both the prevention of such violence and providing better protection for these women. Ahlam’s screams will not be in vain as combined optimism and public outrage will no doubt result in a political uproar and produce tangible legal outcomes.
Image: UN Women via Flickr
