Ding Dong! The vulgarity of Thatcher’s opponents

wicked witch

by Stuart Flegg

Reactions to Thatcher’s death have more to say about society today than that of the late eighties.

On Sunday 14th, the BBC’s Radio 1 chart programme excluded one top ten track from the usual countdown. As a result of a campaign started in 2007 by critics and opponents of Baroness Thatcher, the track “Ding Dong! (The Witch is Dead)” from the 1938 film The Wizard of Oz rose to second in the singles chart.

Sales of the track surged since the death of the former Prime Minister on Monday. The BBC made this move over concerns playing the track would be disrespectful and in poor taste.

The Notsensibles’s tongue-in-cheek protest song “I’m in love with Margret Thatcher” came in at number 35.

Anyone on Twitter or Facebook can’t have failed to notice the great number of impassioned opinions being shared by users. We live in an age where individuals can immediately react and respond to news and content as it happens. An apparent side effect of this is that everyone feels that they must have and opinion and must share this opinion under the misguided idea that anyone else actually cares (my comment-writing self included).

I’m not going to give you my opinion of Thatcherism. As a twenty-year-old, I don’t really have one. Perhaps you can figure out why. Unfortunately not everyone online shares my discretion. If we replace the word ‘Thatcher’ with ‘Thatching’ the illogical thought process becomes clear: “I don’t like thatching. My parents lived under thatching and didn’t like it. Therefore I have decided I do not like thatching either”

It’s ridiculous, nobody would choose roofing materials based on somebody else’s opinion. Take their advice perhaps, but it’s not enough on it’s own to have me actually prefer slate or defect to one of the minor parties and install terracotta tiles. If I do so, it will be my decision.

Some threw street parties to mark the occasion and news of her death was cheered by some delegates at the NUS conference in Sheffield. Not only is this very rude and disrespectful to the conference setting, but I also have a sneaking feeling that this was a unilateral decision by the individuals responsible.

I am however, willing to stand corrected if it turns out all delegates took a straw poll prior to the conference dictating their behaviour in such an eventuality. An elected delegate should never just assume what to do; after all, some students are actually Tories.

Is it in poor taste? Yes. The fact that some people think it appropriate to cheer the death of an 87 year-old woman reveals something rather worrying about our society.

The opponents and critics of Thatcher are absolutely entitled to cheer the ending of her power. But unlike the situation in Munchkinland, (where the significance of the Witch’s death was her inability to do any more witching) Thatcher had already been removed from power. She had been since 1990.

If you wanted to cheer her downfall, you are 23 years too late. And if you weren’t alive then, should you be cheering at all? Thatcher was already out of power; I fail to see how her death could in any way be preferable to that to even the most hard-core critic. Having said that, I’m a bit of a wuss about the whole death thing. I don’t consider the death penalty any better at keeping any individual criminal off the street than life imprisonment would.

Nobody get angry, it’s a metaphor. But it is the fact I can make it which concerns me. The decision for Radio 1 not to play the full track may be wrong in terms of music buyers’ rights. Those who bought the track have been deprived of hearing it on the radio but given that one of the advantages of buying a track is being able to listen to it anyway, I’m not sure that is a valid argument. Station controller, Ben Cooper has made the correct decision in terms of taste, respect and our values towards life.

Those pushing sales of this track are doing so in incredibly poor taste, at least that much is true outside of political thought.