DIM and tdtc Double Bill Showcase review: ‘enjoyable yet mismatched’

By Olivia Race

For one night only Durham Improvised Musical (DIM) and Tone Deaf Theatre Company (tdtc) were brought to The Assembly Rooms Theatre.

The night began with the hour-long Improvised Musical The Christmas Hippopotamus, set in Argos on Black Friday featuring songs such as ‘Help me Santa’. The newly established troupe, Alex Prescot, Charlie Keable, Joe McWilliam, Sophie Forster and Elle Morgan-Williams, with Nick Fleet on the piano, energetically brought this bizarre musical to life with some moments of absolute brilliance.

Keable, it must be noted, was the stand-out performer with the ability to make the whole audience erupt in laughter, even when he had run out of things to say. His interpretative dance accompanying the other two couples’ duets was a particular highlight of the evening.

Prescot must also be commended for his ability to remember what was going on, and to drive the plot and story in a direction that made (a little bit of) sense. There was a definite dip of momentum and direction in the middle when many of the audience members, and many of the performers themselves, seemed to lose all sense of what was happening.

However, the performance was saved at the end with the two full-cast songs, ‘Help me Santa’ and ‘Christmas Hippopotamus’. Although at times the hesitation to come in with the next line of the song, whilst the performer tried to think up a rhyme, was extremely noticeable, in general, they succeed in some excellent musical numbers.

McWilliam and Forster were particularly quick-witted in the songs. Morgan-Williams lacked the energy and confidence of the other performers, but made up for this in the strength of her harmonies. Fleet’s musical cues often lifted the pace and added to the comedy of the piece, and his portrayal of Santa was faultless.

I’m not sure The Christmas Hippopotamus is going to be revived anytime soon but it was definitely worth a watch.

The second half of the evening brought to us the (more) rehearsed musical showcase from tdtc. Although there were some amazing numbers, on the whole, the showcase lacked energy and purpose. As a concept I’m not sure it worked; performing just one song from each musical removed any contextual understanding and generally made it harder to engage and connect, especially with some of the songs being from lesser known, more obscure musicals. Furthermore, the showcase was littered with technical problems throughout which established an awkward expectation for the next issue.

However, criticisms aside, three of the numbers were performed brilliantly and had the entire audience wholly captivated: ‘Do You Know What it’s Like’ from Zanna, Don’t!; ‘Still Hurting’ from The Last 5 Years; and ‘I Know Where I’ve Been’ from Hairspray. Individual stand-out performances came from Finola Southgate, Rachelle Ojomo and Ellie Jones.

The two final full-cast numbers, ‘Oh What A Night’ from Jersey Boys, and ‘Revolting Children’ from Matilda, had the energy the showcase needed throughout, with the performers actually looking like they were enjoying themselves. Although at times you could see the deep look of concentration cross many faces as they tried to remember the next dance move, these two final numbers worked to end the evening on a high.

Photograph: Tom Harrison