Did it Do the Right Thing?

Will Spilsbury assesses Do the Right Thing’s portrayal of African-American culture

CONTROVERSIAL, THOUGHT-PROVOKING AND culturally significant; adjectives that are all among the list of many epithets that have been applied to Spike Lee’s Do The Right Thing: A Spike Lee Joint. Despite some dissenting voices during this period, ever since his independently produced She’s Gotta Have It (1986) had marked a fundamental shift away from the Blaxpoitation era of the 1970s, Spike Lee has been recognised as Hollywood’s most influential black director.

Although Do The Right Thing was not the first of Lee’s feature films, having also produced School Daze (1988) previously, it proved to be easily the most divisive and original of his early work.

The recent celebration of the legacy of Martin Luther King, with media attention given on the 40th anniversary of his assassination by James Earl Ray, whilst celebrating the achievements of a great man, should also remind us that social problems such as criminality, unemployment and poverty still disproportionately affect the African-American community.

Do The Right Thing addresses the problems afflicting the American ghetto in a considered and well-reasoned way, whilst simultaneously depicting a story of some interest and developing fascinating characters.

Taking place over the course of the hottest day of the year, the film addresses racial tensions existing within the Bedford-Stuyvesant section of Brooklyn. ‘Sal’ (Danny Aiello), the Italian owner of his ‘famous pizzeria’, declares at the start that ‘I feel like I’m gonna kill somebody’ and this sets the stage for a series of racially motivated confrontations.

The first flashpoint occurs between ‘Buggin’ Out’ (Giancarlo Esposito) and ‘Sal’, over the lack of African-American heroes on the pizzeria wall. Subsequently, we witness conflict between the local drunk, ‘Da Mayor’ (Ossie Davis), and the Korean owners of the local shop; ‘Pino’ (John Turturro), Sal’s son and a stuttering African-American, ‘Smiley’; all building to the denouement which produced all the controversy.

The final actions of the African-American mob attacking the pizzeria lead to the violent choking of ‘Radio Raheem’ by the police. The ultimate destruction of the pizzeria is provoked by the throwing of a garbage can through the window by Lee’s character, ‘Mookie’. The film ends with two quotes; one from Martin Luther King lamenting the nihilism and self-defeating nature of violence; contrasted with another from Malcolm X, advocating violence in self-defence.

The ultimate message of the piece and Lee’s motivations in referencing Malcolm X and Martin Luther King at the end of Do The Right Thing have provoked much debate. The actions of ‘Mookie’ can be viewed as a justified act of ethical intervention, diverting the violence of the mob away from the owners and on to the property instead.

However, these events can also be interpreted as galvanising the group into attacking the pizzeria in the first place; therefore not an action of justified self-defence. Equally confusing and conflicting was Lee’s decision to juxtapose the quotes of Martin Luther King and Malcolm X: one criticising and the other praising violence in self-defence.

Indeed, a further lack of clarity over the racial situation in America can be seen to stem from Lee’s insistence on blaming whites for the position of blacks; the stifling and frustrating economic condition of the ghetto are testament to this; whilst simultaneously insisting on the individual responsibility of blacks for self-reliance and self-uplift, in highlighting the lack of African-American control of businesses.

Do The Right Thing certainly also displays a decided reverence for African-American culture. The film represents a detailed study of African-American cultural practices; the scene featuring ‘Mother Sister’ having her head scratched is but one example. Indeed, Lee has declared that his films are primarily about black culture.

The director also showed great concern for addressing traditional misconceptions about the ghetto, promoted traditionally by the white media. The choice to set the film during a bright summer day portrayed the black ghetto in a more positive light than had been carried out previously. It is therefore possible to view Do The Right Thing as an attempt by Lee to challenge traditional misconceptions about African-American culture propagated by the white media.

Despite some divided messages over political and social issues, in terms of young African-Americans, Do The Right Thing displayed a genuine attempt to encourage self-uplift and self-determination; messages that are still relevant today.