DICCU as an organisation is neither arrogant nor aggressive

When I sat down to write this article in response to the arguments made by Chris Wright and Edwin Smith about the Durham Inter-Collegiate Christian Union, I faced a conundrum.

Should I simply concede to expectations and aggressively demand to know how an atheist dare question my faith? Or, knowing that my belief is strong enough to withstand criticism, dismiss their comments as merely the ignorant, unenlightened position of two non-believers? I hasten to add that I felt neither position would answer their criticisms appropriately. Was I angered by their arguments? No. Frustrated? Absolutely.

My first experience of the Christian Union was not until the week of events back in my fresher year, 2006. The name of the Main Event was ‘Rescue’. Just as provocative you might say as ‘Know Truth’. Why would I need rescuing?’ I hear you cry. I admit that it did cross my mind, on more than one occasion, that this strongly evangelical form of advertising was possibly not the shrewdest way of winning students round to the Christian Union – let alone causing them to contemplate Christianity seriously. But, whilst I had not attended CU meetings, I had met some of its members from church. Like Edwin, I can say with certainty that they were not the Bible-bashing, socially awkward stereotypes that people mocked freely. On the contrary, they, like me, believed that Jesus Christ’s death on a cross – a punishment reserved for the worst criminals, and a death deserved by us – gave us a way to be restored to God’s favour, avoid an eternity in hell, and be adopted into His family.

This is the truth the CU claim to know. ‘Arrogant’, you still shout. But, to some extent, would not any true faith have to be described as such? The Oxford English Dictionary defines ‘faith’ as ‘Confidence, reliance, trust…in the truth of a statement or doctrine’. For a Christian to have faith in the Bible’s claims does not simply arise from one’s own upbringing or psychological makeup. Yes, it is a personal feeling, an individual faith, but this only comes after being convinced that the evidence to support the audacious claims stands up. The members of CU are willing to discuss their beliefs because, having weighed up the evidence, they have faith in Christianity’s reliability. Christians are convinced that the Bible’s claim that Jesus is both Lord and Saviour is the truth, and that He is truly the Son of God. Only last week a talk asked ‘How can Christians be certain they have the truth?’ Surely if they were in any doubt about the evidence they feel supports the Bible they would not be so eager to give regular opportunities for it to be discussed and questioned.

Chris claimed that the CU was ‘fundamentalist and uncompromising’. A dangerous and provocative accusation given the connotations such a term has today. But, perhaps he had a point. Christians are fundamentalists for they believe that there are certain tenets of the Bible which cannot be compromised – for example, the divinity of Jesus as the Son of God. Surely it cannot be a bad thing to be a fundamentalist if what you claim to have certainty in is the truth.

It is unfortunate that some members may appear aggressive, and admittedly some do have a tendency to strut excessively in their stash. However, I do not think it inconceivable for members of the Christian Union to be tolerant and respectful of other religions or beliefs, and at the same time be committed unswervingly to the Christian faith. Indeed, it is my experience that this is the attitude of most of its members. The Christian Union, far from foisting their beliefs on ‘puzzled passers-by’, encourage anyone attending talks to think personally about the evidence. C. S. Lewis, of Narnia fame, once wrote: “Christianity, if false, is of no importance, and if true, of infinite importance. The only thing it cannot be is moderately important.”

Reader, you may still agree with Chris and Edwin and think the Christian Union is ‘an arrogant and aggressive organisation’ with ‘a strange and silly worldview’. Yet I hope you would understand that it is only because the Christian Union and its members love their friends that they want to tell them how they believe a personal relationship with Jesus brings forgiveness. Durham is full of intelligent and thoughtful students and the Christian Union does not pretend to know what experience of Christianity they may have had. It is because they recognise that students at Durham would want to make careful decisions about such an important issue that they are so keen to invite people to investigate. Accusations of being hypocrites would pierce deeper than calling us ‘fundamentalists’.