Diagnostic change will be disastrous for Selective Mutism sufferers

by Elin Box

Mental illness is common; around 1 in 4 of us will suffer from a mental illness at some point in our lives. Therefore, it is justified to say that the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) – the book used by doctors to diagnose mental illnesses – is a book of great importance. And it is currently being rewritten.

This in itself is a good thing; as more research is done and as our understanding of mental illness develops, it is appropriate that the DSM is updated to take into account these new insights. However, there is growing unease about one particular diagnostic change that has been proposed for a relatively unknown childhood mental illness: Selective Mutism.

The current definition of Selective Mutism categorises it under “other disorders usually first diagnosed in childhood or adolescence” and describes its most prominent feature as a consistent failure to speak (i.e. mutism) in certain (i.e. select) social settings, despite being able to speak in other social settings.

The unusualness of this condition prompts many to incorrectly assume that the child is simply refusing to speak out of stubbornness or as an expression of defiance. This could not be further from the truth. The lack of speech is involuntary and is due to an acute anxiety provoked by the social setting. Many sufferers describe becoming completely overwhelmed by the social situation and their body simply shutting down, rendering them unable to utter a sound.

The new proposed definition of Selective Mutism addresses this central issue of anxiety by changing the categorisation of the disorder, making it a new subtype of Social Anxiety Disorder.

On the surface, this can be viewed as a positive change as it makes it clear, for the first time in the DSM’s history, that the central tenant of the disorder is anxiety. This will no doubt help to dispel the damaging myth that sufferers are remaining mute out of choice. It will also encourage health workers, teachers and parents to tackle the underlying anxiety rather than trying to force the child to speak, a tactic often employed that sadly has the opposite effect and simply puts the sufferer under additional pressure.

However, there will be an unwelcome consequence of this change in classification. The length of time that symptoms must persist before diagnosis, and more crucially treatment, can be provided will be altered drastically. Under the current version of the DSM, symptoms must last for at least one month before a diagnosis of Selective Mutism can be applied.

Under the proposed changes, however, children will have to endure symptoms for at least six months before any diagnosis of Selective Mutism can be made. This is a direct consequence of the change in classification: the six month benchmark is applied to all Social Anxiety Disorders.

This change – extending the period before a diagnosis can be made to six months – could potentially be very damaging to the children involved. It will mean that they have to suffer with the symptoms for an extra five months and, as most cases of Selective Mutism only come to light when the child starts school, this could mean that the child will have to go through the majority of an entire school year without appropriate diagnosis and help.

Most concerning however, is the particularly detrimental effect of time on Selective Mutism. Early intervention is key in treating Selective Mutism, in effect nipping the disorder in the bud before it has a chance to take hold, as the symptoms are extremely self-reinforcing with time.

While the disorder begins with a relatively simple, albeit acute, case of anxiety in a social setting, as time goes on the mutism develops into a habit that quickly becomes engrained and the prospect of breaking this habit causes even greater anxiety – a vicious cycle.

In short, the disorder becomes more entrenched with time and thus harder to treat. Extending the time period needed to elapse before diagnosis in such a time-critical disorder seems extremely unwise and this proposal has caused alarm and despair amongst sufferers and Selective Mutism charities alike.

Mercifully, there was recently a public consultation period when patients, mental health workers and members of the public had the opportunity to give feedback to the DSM writers about the proposed changes. Unfortunately however, this was not widely publicised, although campaigns were launched through Selective Mutism charities and social media websites, urging patients and their parents to use this opportunity to express their views regarding the changes.

Whilst the majority are pleased that Selective Mutism will be classified as a Social Anxiety Disorder, many are against the imposing of a six month benchmark for diagnosis, believing that this will only prolong the suffering of the children and make the disorder more severe.

This public consultation period has now ended, so now all advocates can do is wait, and hope that the writers of the DSM will rethink their position on a minimum six month wait before diagnosis of this crippling, time-critical, childhood mental illness.